20-Year-Old Student Weighs New Hybrid vs. Used Car: Is a $27k Corolla Worth the Financial Trade-off?
- Age
- 20
- Net Worth
- $23,000
- Profession
- Student
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 20-year-old student is balancing a $23k nest egg with the desire for a reliable car. They are carefully weighing the long-term impact of a $27k vehicle purchase on their early savings.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Your current savings rate is excellent for a student. Prioritizing reliable transportation is a valid investment in your future employability.
Areas to Focus
- • Avoid a new car loan; purchase a reliable $10k used vehicle to preserve your investment capital and cash flow.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Committing a significant portion of your monthly income to a car payment while in school could jeopardize your ability to build your emergency fund.
The Original Post
Hi! I'm a 20 year old college student, and I'm in a pretty fortunate situation. My parents allow me to live with them rent free, and due to scholarships I do not have to pay for housing or tuition at my university. I have had a part time job, and have saved up a decent amount of money, 7k in a retirement account, and 16k in savings/invested. So my question is, should I use some of what I have saved to buy a car? I currently do not have one, and take the bus/bike everywhere, which has worked well enough but is very inconvenient at times, has limited what I can do recreationally, and has once limited a job opportunity as I could not reasonably reach the job site as well. I know I could buy a used car for decently cheap, but would it be worth it to buy a car new? What I'm looking at is the Toyota Corolla Hybrid, which is 27k, so I could put 10-12k down and pay 4-500 monthly for 3 years, or less if I got a longer plan. They hold their value really well, since they're supposed to be reliable, so it's not like I'd be losing all that money, plus it's a hybrid so gas wouldn't be as bad. But I also feel like I'm trying to justify an unnecessary expense to myself, and 500 a month isn't a negligible amount; it's most of what I'd be making during a school month, and around half what I'd make during the summer months. Plus, that's not including insurance. I still have to budget for groceries for myself and such after paying for this. So. Is it worth it? Should I just stick to getting a used car (and if so, any recommendations on price range & models?)? Or should I just stick to transit and biking