FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Should I rent after college or take out a mortgage on real estate?

r/FinancialPlanning
7/13/2025
Age
20
Net Worth
$64,000

Summary

At 20 years old, this individual has a strong financial foundation with no student debt, a significant amount saved in retirement and investment accounts, and a high-paying job lined up after graduation. Purchasing a property with a USDA loan could be a wise long-term investment, providing the freedom to build a self-sufficient lifestyle in a rural area while accumulating equity. However, the potential challenges of home ownership, such as maintenance costs and reduced mobility, should be carefully considered.

The Original Post

Some background: I'm 20 years old, and I was very fortunate to have gotten a full tuition work/study scholarship for college. The scholarship also comes with a fairly large stipend, which I've been saving 90% of. My parents and grandparents collectively saved enough money for me to go to college for 2 years, so they gifted me that money to be used solely for room & board. So I'm graduating college with no debt. Right now, I have $16,000 in my 401k, with another $8,000 in a Roth IRA. Additionally, I have about $40,000 in a general investment account. Assuming that I have a net 0% return, and I follow my spending budget, my general investment account should have $65,000 by the time I graduate college. Anyway, for a few weeks, I've been thinking about if I should rent after college, or buy real estate via mortgage. My scholarship gives a guaranteed job upon graduation, which will pay >$100,000/year. I want to live out in a rural area, and commute to the city. I could do this by buying land and getting a manufactured home, which a USDA loan would cover. I did some math and research, and this would cost $250,000. USDA loans allow for any down payment amount, and do not charge PMI. So I could put $25,000 down, and the mortgage payments, including taxes and insurance, would be less than 20% of $100,000/year. Pros of mortgage: * I'd own 2+ acres of land and would have freedom to do (almost) whatever I want with it. I want to have a self-sufficient garden and I need land for this. * I'd be gaining equity instead of bleeding money from renting. Manufactured homes, when bought new and deeded to a permanent foundation, appreciate in value. Cons of mortgage: * I'd be tied to the house. If I want to move, it would be much harder to sell the property due to it being in a rural area. * If something breaks, I'd have to pay out of pocket to fix it. * Living in a rural area means I'd have to plan out going to the store (i.e. on the way home from work) What should I do? This is years out in the future, I just want to find out if my idea of getting a mortgage after college is a bad idea.