FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Is a $35k Car Purchase Justifiable for a 23-Year-Old Engineer with $41k Net Worth?

r/FinancialPlanning
5/29/2026
Age
23
Net Worth
$41,100
Income
$70,000/yr
Expenses
$33,600/yr
Profession
Structural Engineer
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This 23-year-old structural engineer is balancing strong savings with the desire to upgrade from a 2009 vehicle, questioning if a $35k car is a reasonable financial move.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have a great savings rate and zero debt, which puts you well ahead of your peers at 23.

Areas to Focus

  • • Prioritize maxing your Roth IRA and employer 401k match before diverting funds toward a depreciating luxury asset like the GR86.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Reducing monthly investments for a car purchase at age 23 significantly impacts long-term compounding growth.

The Original Post

I’ll start this off with some backstory. I’m 23, and make 70k a year as a structural engineer, having just graduated college a year ago. I’m expecting a pay bump to 77.5k at the end of this year, 85k at the end of the next, before plateauing and slowing growth a little bit around the high 90s/low 100s range the year after that. Currently I have zero debt whatsoever, my rent is $1200 (split it with girlfriend proportional to income) so I have around \~$1200 at the end of the month to save invest. Currently my accounts look like this: Brokerage account: $16,100 + $300 Monthly (18% ROR currently, I know this is not constant) Money market account: $7400 + $500 Monthly (\~3.5% rate, consistent) Roth IRA: $14,600 + $200 Monthly (14% average return over \~5 years, I’ve had this account the longest by far) Every couple months I take remaining cash from my checking and just allocate it to either 401k I contribute 6% and my employer matches 5% but specific amounts are not relevant to this topic. I also keep a cash buffer of $3k in my checking at all times for emergency expenses. Anyway now here’s my conundrum. I own a 2009 CRV, thing is fully paid off and I paid like $800 for a full years insurance. Engine works fine but there are a couple of minor little things with the car that bug me since it was bought as a salvage title like the trunk not opening unless the car is on or the doors not being able to be locked remotely. Im looking into getting a new (or a couple years old) car at the end of this year once the Christmas bonus and raise hit, specifically eyeballing a Toyota GR86 (around $30-$35k after taxes and fees and all that BS). Anyway, I maybe it’s because I was raised to be so frugal, but I feel really guilty about wanting to buy this car. I should have around $20k in the brokerage account by then and around $10k in the MM (Japan trip in September so taking a couple thousand out) permitted the returns stay the same through December. I plan on taking around 7k from my brokerage account by then and 3k from my money market, with my Christmas bonus (probably in the low $2ks) for a \~12-13k down payment. I’ve done the math already insurance considered and know I can reasonably afford this car with cutting my investments maybe a couple hundred a month for a year but for some reason it feels unjustifiable to me buy this (or any) car. My little brother is getting his license this year so I plan on selling my current car to him for like $1k. Is this a reasonable purchase or should I just hold onto my current car until it shits the bed? I plan on holding onto the new car for many years if I go through with it.