Is a $35k Car Purchase Justifiable for a 23-Year-Old Engineer with $41k Net Worth?
- Age
- 23
- Net Worth
- $41,100
- Income
- $70,000/yr
- Expenses
- $33,600/yr
- Profession
- Structural Engineer
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 23-year-old structural engineer is balancing strong savings with the desire to upgrade from a 2009 vehicle, questioning if a $35k car is a reasonable financial move.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a great savings rate and zero debt, which puts you well ahead of your peers at 23.
Areas to Focus
- • Prioritize maxing your Roth IRA and employer 401k match before diverting funds toward a depreciating luxury asset like the GR86.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Reducing monthly investments for a car purchase at age 23 significantly impacts long-term compounding growth.
The Original Post
I’ll start this off with some backstory. I’m 23, and make 70k a year as a structural engineer, having just graduated college a year ago. I’m expecting a pay bump to 77.5k at the end of this year, 85k at the end of the next, before plateauing and slowing growth a little bit around the high 90s/low 100s range the year after that. Currently I have zero debt whatsoever, my rent is $1200 (split it with girlfriend proportional to income) so I have around \~$1200 at the end of the month to save invest. Currently my accounts look like this: Brokerage account: $16,100 + $300 Monthly (18% ROR currently, I know this is not constant) Money market account: $7400 + $500 Monthly (\~3.5% rate, consistent) Roth IRA: $14,600 + $200 Monthly (14% average return over \~5 years, I’ve had this account the longest by far) Every couple months I take remaining cash from my checking and just allocate it to either 401k I contribute 6% and my employer matches 5% but specific amounts are not relevant to this topic. I also keep a cash buffer of $3k in my checking at all times for emergency expenses. Anyway now here’s my conundrum. I own a 2009 CRV, thing is fully paid off and I paid like $800 for a full years insurance. Engine works fine but there are a couple of minor little things with the car that bug me since it was bought as a salvage title like the trunk not opening unless the car is on or the doors not being able to be locked remotely. Im looking into getting a new (or a couple years old) car at the end of this year once the Christmas bonus and raise hit, specifically eyeballing a Toyota GR86 (around $30-$35k after taxes and fees and all that BS). Anyway, I maybe it’s because I was raised to be so frugal, but I feel really guilty about wanting to buy this car. I should have around $20k in the brokerage account by then and around $10k in the MM (Japan trip in September so taking a couple thousand out) permitted the returns stay the same through December. I plan on taking around 7k from my brokerage account by then and 3k from my money market, with my Christmas bonus (probably in the low $2ks) for a \~12-13k down payment. I’ve done the math already insurance considered and know I can reasonably afford this car with cutting my investments maybe a couple hundred a month for a year but for some reason it feels unjustifiable to me buy this (or any) car. My little brother is getting his license this year so I plan on selling my current car to him for like $1k. Is this a reasonable purchase or should I just hold onto my current car until it shits the bed? I plan on holding onto the new car for many years if I go through with it.