FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

From $150k at 24 to FI at 35: Should This Engaged Couple Ditch Their 401k Strategy?

r/financialindependence
4/16/2026
Age
24
Net Worth
$150,000
Income
$145,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

24-year-old with $150k NW and $145k HHI on track for FI by 35 faces strategic decision between traditional 401k contributions and taxable investments. Clear FIRE focus with strong savings rate, though needs to clarify annual expenses to optimize tax strategy.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Maxing 401k, Roth IRA, and HSA contributions ($23,500 + $7,000 + $4,150 = $34,650 annually) while aggressively paying down student loans shows disciplined multi-account strategy. At age 24 with $150k NW and $145k HHI, the couple has a 38% potential savings rate and 11-year horizon to reach $1.3M+ needed for age-35 FI.

Areas to Focus

  • • Calculate exact annual expenses (non-negotiable for FIRE planning). Once known, use 25x rule to determine target FI number, then decide: traditional 401k maximization makes sense if expenses are low enough that Roth conversions during low-income years (before age 59.5) are feasible, but taxable accounts offer more flexibility for your aggressive 11-year timeline.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Relying on early withdrawal strategies (72t, Roth ladder) without fully modeling your actual retirement spending. The financial advisor's point about future tax rates deserves serious analysis—if you believe taxes will be 35%+ in retirement, taxable might win, but most FIRE practitioners find traditional 401k optimization + Roth ladder more optimal. Also, student loan payoff is consuming investment capacity now; ensure this doesn't extend beyond 1-2 years and doesn't derail the 11-year FI goal.

The Original Post

Current situation: 24 yo, getting married this summer. Our finances are pretty much already combined. NW \~150k, mostly in cash and equities. Goal is to be FI in 11ish years by age 35. Currently on track to max my trad. 401k, Roth IRA, and HSA this year. From research and reading this sub, I thought even if you wanted to access funds before 59.5, the trad 401k was still probably best. We had a free session with a financial advisor recently just for the heck of it. He suggested lowering 401k contributions to just get employer match and either switch to Roth 401k or taxable investments. The rationale being that 401k money is locked up and you have to pay income tax on it even if using early withdrawal methods (72t, Roth ladder). And he argues that tax rates are likely to go up (even if we were to go down in brackets). This point makes relative sense to me but everything I've read says max traditional 401k -> HSA -> Roth IRA -> taxable investments. I definitely do want to contribute to taxable investments since the goal is aggresive. This year we are paying off student loans aggresively so are only investing a few hundred per month in taxable (and aren't budgeting to max my spouses roth IRA). So in future years we likely could max my spouses Roth IRA as well and contribute more to taxable investments. But what is the general consensus? Does it make sense to continue in traditional 401k or take some of that and put it into taxable accounts instead. TYIA Also if this context helps, HHI is 140-150k