FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Is a $70k Sports Car Worth It? A 24-Year-Old Engineer's Financial Dilemma

r/FinancialPlanning
7/6/2026
Age
24
Net Worth
$159,000
Income
$250,000/yr
Expenses
$60,000/yr
Location
VHCOL area
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This 24-year-old high earner is weighing a $70k luxury car purchase against their long-term financial independence goals while maintaining a healthy investment base.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You are maxing out your 401k and utilizing back-door Roth IRAs, which puts you well ahead of your peers.

Areas to Focus

  • • Calculate the total opportunity cost of that $10k down payment plus the extra $1k/month over a 10-year period compounded at 7%.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Overestimating the resale value of a luxury vehicle in a volatile market while locking up significant capital in a depreciating asset.

The Original Post

I’m a huge car enthusiast but have never had the chance to own a “fun” car. I currently drive an EV that I chose to purchase a couple years ago due to the tax credits. Lately I’ve been having a huge itch to get something more exciting, but I am stuck in analysis paralysis and don’t want to make a financial decision I’d regret later in life. Some background: \- 24yo in a VHCOL area \- Base salary \~$168k, total comp \~$240k-$250k including bonus and RSUs. \- Ignoring RSUs/bonus, after taxes and deductions my take home salary is \~$7700/mo. Generally have $3-4k worth of RSUs vesting monthly after taxes. \- $45k in cash, mostly in an HYSA. $30k is earmarked as an emergency fund. \- $80k in my 401k (will continue to max out my contributions as my employer matches 50%) and $9k in my roth IRA (only started contributing this year via backdoor, will continue every year going forward). \- $70k combined across my taxable brokerage accounts. \- My total monthly spend currently hovers around $4500-5000. Rent + utilities is $2250/mo and other fixed expenses (car insurance, recurring medical costs etc) add up to \~$450/mo. I can reduce my discretionary spending slightly but would prefer not to. \- No debt currently apart from what this car would add. The car: 2024+ BMW M2, \~$60k used or $70k new before taxes. These cars have held their value relatively well over time (but I’m not assuming that this will always hold true in the future). The math I’ve run: \- Down payment will be the proceeds from my current vehicle (\~$20k if traded in, slightly more if private party). I’d probably put an additional $10-15k down (will save up a bit further for this) \- Preapproved for a 4.49% APR 60mo loan through my credit union. Monthly payment in the mid $600 range depending on down payment. \- Car insurance quotes look very similar to what I’m paying currently. Maintenance will definitely cost more (budgeting $150/mo), but the car will be under warranty. Fuel will also cost more, probably $200/mo. AFAIK the net impact to my finances would essentially be a $10k hit to cash/investments, and my monthly spend increasing by \~$1k. Not looking to be told “go buy a Camry instead”. I’ve already decided this is a purchase I want to make for non-financial reasons. I know on paper the answer is that I can afford this as the payments and car value are well under most % guidelines. My primary question is whether I’m correctly assessing the total cost of ownership, and if there’s any other consideration (such as any opportunity costs or risks) that I should think about further. Thanks everyone!