FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Am I making a mistake renting instead of buying for my first time moving out at 25?

r/FinancialPlanning
2/3/2025
Age
25
Net Worth
$105,000

Summary

The individual appears to be in a strong financial position, with a significant amount of savings and no outstanding debts. While renting may be more affordable in the short term, buying a property could be a wise long-term investment, provided they are comfortable with the additional responsibilities and costs associated with homeownership.

The Original Post

25M, single, making ~$82.5k/year. I have roughly $75k saved between HYSA and regular checking/savings (majority is in HYSA), and $30k in my 401k. I’ve never moved out of our family home and feel like it is time for many reasons. My only debt is my car lease, which I can’t wait to get rid of / or just buy out at the end and drive until the wheels fall off. No student loans, no CC debt. I have my spending / finances under pretty good control. I applied for a townhouse rental and got approved, but am now having cold feet whether I’m making a mistake on renting instead of just jumping into the market by buying. I live in the Midwest. **Townhouse rental is $1720/mo** not including utilities. This is “fair”for renting in my specific area/market, especially considering it’s newer (built in 2020) with a nice layout, attached garage, and community. A comparable condo/townhouse to buy around my area varies anywhere from $230k-$375k, and from my research most HOAs are on average $275/mo. I found a condo that is somewhat “apartment” styled as you live above someone else, and it is for $230k. I’m not crazy about the idea of living above someone as I don’t want to feel like I have to “walk on egg shells”, especially considering I work as a night shift nurse. It is, however, 1600sq ft and pretty nice. There are quite a few around the same price range as this condo community is huge. It still has a private attached garage. With **20% down at 7% interest rate**, all-in it looks like it’d be around the **$1900/mo range to buy**. I also found a similar one that isn’t above another condo (it is still a raised ranch condo) for $285k, and with 20% down + 7% interest rate + taxes/HOA/insurance, it’ll be around **$2100/mo**. So… I feel like I am at a total standstill and am panicked on what to do. Would I be making a financially bad decision by renting instead of buying considering I can relatively afford both?