Saving Money on Rent vs. Quality of Life
- Age
- 25
- Net Worth
- $140,000
Summary
The poster is a 25-year-old female living in a small, noisy apartment in downtown Manhattan with a roommate. Despite the apartment's downsides, the rent is relatively low, allowing the poster to save and invest a significant portion of their income. The poster is considering moving to a nicer apartment, but is concerned about the higher cost and potential impact on their savings rate. Overall, the poster is in a strong financial position with a substantial net worth and no debt.
The Original Post
Hi r/financialplanning I’m 25F and have been in the same apartment since 2021 in prime downtown Manhattan. I moved with a COVID deal paying $1.2K and since it has increased to $1750, with utilities running ~$60-75/month (my portion). I never thought I’d be here for more than a year, and now my lease renewal is set for end of May and I’m on the fence of whether to move or not. Currently in a 2br/1bath 4th floor pre-war walk up and I really like my roommate who is willing to resign. Management/maintenance has always been a positive experience, feel safe in the building, no bugs or rats. Downsides are no closets in the entire apartment (have learned to be very minimal), poor natural sunlight, and on a loud/busy street from bars and road/traffic noise. Also bedrooms are incredibly small with lofted beds (I can touch the walls with my hands in terms of width). Given the general “rent should not be more than 30% of gross monthly income” rule, based on my current salary I could afford $2.8K in rent/utilites. However just because I can, doesn’t mean I should and given my rent costs being low I have been able to save/invest the difference which is important to me to live below my means. No consumer or student debt, ~$140k net worth. The other factor I’m considering that is hard to assign a tangible cost to is my personal growth and development. The idea of staying 4 years in one apartment (from age 21-25) I’m not 100% in love with sometimes feels hard to accept, but worth the sacrifice given price + location. But I have been told that moving and experiencing other spaces/environments/neighborhoods can vastly improve quality of life/change your perspective. So I wonder, is it worth moving despite knowing I will likely never be able to find rent as cheap as I have it now in downtown Manhattan? As I will inevitably be raising my cost of living/reducing my disposable income/savings rate? But in theory by moving to a “better” apartment my quality of life improves but at a higher cost. Or do I continue to suck it up and stay where I am to continue to save or move for a more qualitative reason that may or may not make a large difference (ie. is the grass really greener?) Would love any insight or advice! Thanks!