FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

25 Years Old with $183k Net Worth: Strategy for Roth vs Traditional 401k

r/Fire
9/10/2026
Age
25
Net Worth
$183,100
Income
$102,000/yr
Location
Upstate NY
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 25, this investor has built a $183k portfolio and is optimizing tax strategies to hit FIRE by age 45.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Maximizing 401k, Roth IRA, and HSA contributions is excellent discipline for someone at age 25.

Areas to Focus

  • • Calculate your projected retirement expenses more accurately to determine if your $80k withdrawal goal aligns with your current savings trajectory.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-optimizing for future tax brackets while ignoring the immediate cash flow advantage of Traditional 401k tax deductions.

The Original Post

Should I contribute more to a Roth 401k or keep all my money in a trad 401k? I make 102k a year 100k a year after my health insurance comes out no fica deductions after that. Currently I invest the following a year in upstate NY so no city tax: 401k 24.5k Roth IRA 7.5k HSA 4.4k (no fica deduction employer doesn't offer HSA) Brokerage 10k I take the standard deduction and have 1k in student loan interest as a tax deduction I can take. If I max out my 401k with trad my brackets are below: Fed: 22% Fica 7.65% State: 5.5% If Roth 401k: 22% 7.65% 6% 25,711 vs 17,716 for trad vs 401k taxes so I'll invest 8k less in the brokerage if I switch from trad to Roth. I have the following assets: 64.5k in Roth 75.4k IRA/401k 14.5k HSA 12.7k brokerage 16k emergency fund 183k total at age 25. I want to retire at 45 no matter what with whatever assets I have. My job is boring but stable and I don't work very hard I just hate working when I could be doing anything else. Hopefully I get 80k adjusted for inflation after a 3-4% withdrawal but who knows. Should I use the Roth 401k more than I do because they have to raise taxes to get the national debt under control which means more tax later. We know the us will not cut spending. Or should I just keep maxing my trad and then roll it over if I ever lose my job or retire early?