FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

25-Year-Old Maxing IRAs with $45k Saved - Which 401k Rollover Move Wins?

r/FinancialPlanning
11/4/2025
Age
25
Net Worth
$45,000
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

25-year-old with $45k across retirement accounts strategically maxing IRA contributions, navigating 401k rollover decision after employer plan change.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Maxing IRA contributions ($7k/year) at fiscal year start is excellent - you're leveraging time in market. At 25 with $45k saved, you're ahead of 90% of peers. Smart thinking about fee analysis with Voya before committing.

Areas to Focus

  • • Roll the $16k Principal 401k into your Fidelity Traditional IRA immediately - consolidate accounts, eliminate future orphaned 401k fees, and maintain full control with low-cost index funds at Fidelity.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Waiting on the rollover decision costs you - once your employer stops covering Principal fees, you'll face administrative charges that eat returns. Also, if you get a new job, you'll have multiple orphaned 401ks creating tracking complexity and potential fee stacking.

The Original Post

Hi yall, my employer changed 401k plans from Principal to Voya. I have a little more than 16k in my Principal 401k and I’m wondering if I should: a. Keep it in Principal (can’t contribute more but it could continue to grow? Not sure what fees I would face by prolonging when I’d eventually roll over since right now my employer’s covering the fees) b. Roll it over into Voya (I’ve heard bad things about them but idk) c. Roll it over into my traditional IRA in Fidelity (I have 29k in there, I max out the 7k annual contribution limit at the start of every fiscal year) I’m honestly not sure what is my best option. For reference, I’m just about to turn 25 next month so I have a while to save up but I want to make the most of it. The things I’ve seen online about high fees with Voya makes me not want to use it at all, but I can’t even contribute to my Principal 401k anymore. I could always make a Roth IRA and roll my Principal 401k over into there, but then I won’t be able to contribute to my retirement as much as I can with both IRA and 401k. There is the chance that I get a new job within the next year too, if the job market permits (lol), and so I may not be in this situation with a not-so-great 401k plan for too long, but who knows. Would greatly appreciate any insight, thank you so much!