From $35k to $72k: How a 25-Year-Old's Annuity Mistake Could Still Pay Off
- Age
- 25
- Net Worth
- $72,788
- FIRE Status
- Behind
Summary
At 25 years old, this individual invested $35k in a variable annuity with high fees, but the investment has since grown to $72k. Though it wasn't the best choice, they now have options to either keep the annuity, annuitize it for lifetime income, or surrender and reinvest the $72k for potentially higher returns.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • The annuity has grown to $72,788, which is a good start to their net worth at 25 years old.
Areas to Focus
- • Consider surrendering the annuity and reinvesting the $72k in a low-cost index fund like VT to potentially earn higher returns and get their FIRE plan back on track.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ The high 3% fees on the annuity have been eroding their potential investment growth over the past 15 years.
The Original Post
Back in 2009 when I was young and inexperienced I had 35k to invest. My financial advisor sold me on a MetLife MLI USA Variable Annuity Series C with a GMIB of 6% and a yearly step-up feature, and death benefit. 6% guaranteed sounded pretty good to me and I didn't really understand then about how much 3% fees were eating away at the compounding. 15 years later, the Actual Cash Value (and surrender value) is $72,788.45. The guaranteed income base is $91,343.74 and will grow 6% a year as well as "step up" higher if actual cash value is larger. What a stupid investment to out a 25 year old into. I don't want to continue bleeding on this if it would make more sense to surrender and invest elsewhere with a low fee. Should I: Keep it * Shrug Oh well, keep it. At age 60 I can either take payments based on the actual value or annuitize and take payments for life, I would have to live for awhile to make my value back. Also there is the death benefit. Annuitize it * Since it has been 10 years since I opened it, I am now able to take GMIB income for life. I am 43. I could take $5,334.74 a year. I would owe income tax using exclusion ratio and 10% penalty from IRS Surrender and reinvest for better returns * I would owe income tax on $37,788.45. I would have to pay a 10% penalty on that amount. Reinvest into VT. Don't buy annuities!