FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

From $35k to $72k: How a 25-Year-Old's Annuity Mistake Could Still Pay Off

r/Fire
10/9/2025
Age
25
Net Worth
$72,788
FIRE Status
Behind

Summary

At 25 years old, this individual invested $35k in a variable annuity with high fees, but the investment has since grown to $72k. Though it wasn't the best choice, they now have options to either keep the annuity, annuitize it for lifetime income, or surrender and reinvest the $72k for potentially higher returns.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • The annuity has grown to $72,788, which is a good start to their net worth at 25 years old.

Areas to Focus

  • • Consider surrendering the annuity and reinvesting the $72k in a low-cost index fund like VT to potentially earn higher returns and get their FIRE plan back on track.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The high 3% fees on the annuity have been eroding their potential investment growth over the past 15 years.

The Original Post

Back in 2009 when I was young and inexperienced I had 35k to invest. My financial advisor sold me on a MetLife MLI USA Variable Annuity Series C with a GMIB of 6% and a yearly step-up feature, and death benefit. 6% guaranteed sounded pretty good to me and I didn't really understand then about how much 3% fees were eating away at the compounding. 15 years later, the Actual Cash Value (and surrender value) is $72,788.45. The guaranteed income base is $91,343.74 and will grow 6% a year as well as "step up" higher if actual cash value is larger. What a stupid investment to out a 25 year old into. I don't want to continue bleeding on this if it would make more sense to surrender and invest elsewhere with a low fee. Should I: Keep it * Shrug Oh well, keep it. At age 60 I can either take payments based on the actual value or annuitize and take payments for life, I would have to live for awhile to make my value back. Also there is the death benefit. Annuitize it * Since it has been 10 years since I opened it, I am now able to take GMIB income for life. I am 43. I could take $5,334.74 a year. I would owe income tax using exclusion ratio and 10% penalty from IRS Surrender and reinvest for better returns * I would owe income tax on $37,788.45. I would have to pay a 10% penalty on that amount. Reinvest into VT. Don't buy annuities!