27-Year-Old Weighing 401k Loan vs. Withdrawal to Tackle $8.7k in High-Interest Credit Card Debt
- Age
- 27
- Net Worth
- $15,270
- Income
- $75,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- Behind
Summary
At 27, you are taking ownership of your debt. While the inheritance provides a safety net, avoiding the 30% penalty of a withdrawal will keep your financial progress on track.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Focus on the 401k loan to avoid the 30% tax and penalty hit, ensuring your long-term growth is not derailed by high-interest debt.
Areas to Focus
- • Create a strict 12-month budget to pay off the $8,730 debt without relying on further retirement account erosion.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ The high interest on the credit cards is compounding faster than your 401k returns, but withdrawing could cost you significantly in taxes.
The Original Post
Quick context: I have about $8,730 in credit card debt across two cards (one at 18.49% APR, one at 25.74% APR). I make $75k/year, my partner makes $82k and have roughly $24k in my 401k. I'm leaning toward taking a 401k loan**,** my plan offers 7.75% interest, $50 origination fee, $25/year maintenance, and I can choose my own term (looking at 12 months). I've seen some posts from people who took a straight withdrawal instead which would be nice to just get rid of all my debt. Obviously eating the \~30%+ tax + penalty hit is a much bigger loss, but a few of them describe feeling more "free" doing it that way. My parents have paid off my card a few times and I feel so guilty asking them to do it again. I want to try to solve it on my own. One thing that makes my situation a little different: I have a substantial inheritance expected around retirement age, so I'm personally less anxious than most about hitting a specific retirement number by 65. That said, I know "I'll have money later" doesn't make today's tax/penalty hit on a withdrawal any cheaper, and I don't want to use that as an excuse to make a worse financial decision just because it feels more "done." Any advice would be really helpful! For those who've actually done a 401k loan vs. a withdrawal for debt payoff: * Did the loan repayment feel manageable alongside normal expenses, or did it strain your budget more than expected? * Anyone regret choosing one over the other? Trying to make a wise decision rather than an emotional one