27-Year-Old Software Engineer with $215k Portfolio Struggles with Comparison Trap
- Age
- 27
- Net Worth
- $247,000
- Income
- $115,000/yr
- Profession
- Software Engineer
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 27-year-old software engineer has saved $215k in retirement, yet feels behind due to comparing their path against a hypothetical no-college scenario.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a stellar $215k net worth at 27, which puts you well ahead of your peers; focusing on your own growth rather than hypothetical scenarios is key.
Areas to Focus
- • Stop comparing your path to imaginary benchmarks and start setting concrete, personal FIRE goals based on your specific cost of living.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Mental burnout from constant social comparison and dissatisfaction despite strong financial health.
The Original Post
I am 27 and make about $110k base, around $115k with my normal bonus. I work in software. My current retirement accounts are roughly: \* $156k Roth IRA \* $41k Traditional IRA \* $14.75k 401(k), split about 50/50 Roth and Traditional And my EF is 15k and I have about 20k set for a car so around 210k in retirement and a little more buffet for emergencies. I know objectively that this is a good amount for my age. I am not trying to say I am poor or in a bad financial situation. The problem is that I created this imaginary version of myself who never went to college, and I keep feeling like I have to beat him. College took me about five years. Tuition itself was roughly $60k, but if I include housing, food, and other living costs during those years, I estimate the total cost at around \\\~140k. At the same time, I was not working full time and investing during those years. So I built a hypothetical. Imagine I skipped college in 2017, got a normal job, and invested 1k a month from 2017 - 2026. That is: $1,000 × 12 × 10 years =120,000$ Then I also give this imaginary version of myself another huge advantage. I assume the 140k i paid in college went toward S&P 500 in 2022 as it would be unrealistic for me to think I would invest from 2017 - 2022 however at the end of 2022 I think it would be realistic. I know that part is unrealistic. The $140k did not exist as one giant pile of cash that I could magically invest. I estimate by end of 2026 this is around 530k, meanwhile actual me has around 215k. That $315k gap bothers me more than it probably should. There is another important detail. I lived at home through 2026 after college aside for one year, which obviously helped me save. I do not want to pretend I built everything with zero family advantage. Not paying normal market rent gave me a big opportunity to put money into retirement accounts. Going forward, though, I think my situation becomes more interesting. I currently make much more than the hypothetical job I imagine no-college me having. For the model, I assume no-college me earns around $55k and eventually has normal living expenses that slightly exceed his take-home pay. Starting in 2027, I assume he has to withdraw 150$ from his investment to cover the gap. I also increase that $150 withdrawal by 2% inflation every year So it looks roughly like: Year 1: $150/month Year 2: $153/month Year 3: $156/month Year 10: about $179/month Year 20: about $219/month Year 30: about $266/month For my actual path, I assume I keep investing 1750$ a month for both portfolios, I use a 6% rate of return going forward. I am purposely not using 9% or 10% because I would rather plan conservatively. Starting with 530k for no-college me and 215k for actual me, my rough calculation says that by age 59½: No College Me: 3.45M College Me: 3.55M Under those assumptions, I finally catch the imaginary version of myself around age 55. Obviously this model is not reality. Most of my accounts I will rollover to Roth before I retire and the other account is in brokerage however it is semi-realistic. Then I see friends who lived with parents who covered housing and food, or people in big tech making $400k, $700k, or even seven figures, and suddenly my own progress feels small. Example is one of my coworkers never made 100k but at same age living at home saved like \\\~400k liquid and \\\~100k in his retirement as he did not spend at all. I just feel so behind and even sad I did worse then had i never went to college. Any advice?