FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Is College A Mistake? My $247k Net Worth vs. My Hypothetical $530k Self

r/coastFIRE
9/22/2026
Age
27
Net Worth
$247,000
Income
$115,000/yr
Profession
Software Engineer
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 27, this software engineer has saved $247k but feels behind due to comparing their path against a hypothetical no-college scenario and high-earning peers.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have built an impressive $247k by age 27, which puts you well ahead of your peers; focusing on your own high earning potential in software is a strong strategy.

Areas to Focus

  • • Stop comparing your financial path to imaginary scenarios and focus on optimizing your actual 6% return projections.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The 'comparison trap' is your biggest risk, as it ignores your superior long-term earning ceiling in tech compared to a $55k hypothetical career path.

The Original Post

I am 27 and make about $110k base, around $115k with my normal bonus. I work in software. My current retirement accounts are roughly: • $156k Roth IRA • $41k Traditional IRA • $14.75k 401(k), split about 50/50 Roth and Traditional And my EF is 15k and I have about 20k set for a car so around 210k in retirement and a little more buffet for emergencies. I know objectively that this is a good amount for my age. I am not trying to say I am poor or in a bad financial situation. The problem is that I created this imaginary version of myself who never went to college, and I keep feeling like I have to beat him. College took me about five years. Tuition itself was roughly $60k, but if I include housing, food, and other living costs during those years, I estimate the total cost at around \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\~140k. At the same time, I was not working full time and investing during those years. So I built a hypothetical. Imagine I skipped college in 2017, got a normal job, and invested 1k a month from 2017 - 2026. That is: $1,000 × 12 × 10 years =120,000$ Then I also give this imaginary version of myself another huge advantage. I assume the 140k i paid in college went toward S&P 500 in 2022 as it would be unrealistic for me to think I would invest from 2017 - 2022 however at the end of 2022 I think it would be realistic. I know that part is unrealistic. The $140k did not exist as one giant pile of cash that I could magically invest. I estimate by end of 2026 this is around 530k, meanwhile actual me has around 215k. That $315k gap bothers me more than it probably should. There is another important detail. I lived at home through 2026 after college aside for one year, which obviously helped me save. I do not want to pretend I built everything with zero family advantage. Not paying normal market rent gave me a big opportunity to put money into retirement accounts. Going forward, though, I think my situation becomes more interesting. I currently make much more than the hypothetical job I imagine no-college me having. For the model, I assume no-college me earns around $55k and eventually has normal living expenses that slightly exceed his take-home pay. Starting in 2027, I assume he has to withdraw 150$ from his investment to cover the gap. I also increase that $150 withdrawal by 2% inflation every year So it looks roughly like: Year 1: $150/month Year 2: $153/month Year 3: $156/month Year 10: about $179/month Year 20: about $219/month Year 30: about $266/month For my actual path, I assume I keep investing 1750$ a month for both portfolios, I use a 6% rate of return going forward. I am purposely not using 9% or 10% because I would rather plan conservatively. Starting with 530k for no-college me and 215k for actual me, my rough calculation says that by age 59½: No College Me: 3.45M College Me: 3.55M Under those assumptions, I finally catch the imaginary version of myself around age 55. Obviously this model is not reality. Most of my accounts I will rollover to Roth before I retire and the other account is in brokerage however it is semi-realistic. Then I see friends who lived with parents who covered housing and food, or people in big tech making $400k, $700k, or even seven figures, and suddenly my own progress feels small. Example is one of my coworkers never made 100k but at same age living at home saved like \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\~400k liquid and \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\~100k in his retirement as he did not spend at all. I just feel so behind and even sad I did worse then had i never went to college. Any advice?