Pension vs Portfolio: How This 27-Year-Old Government Worker Is Building $1M by 55
- Age
- 27
- Net Worth
- $38,000
- Profession
- Government Worker
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
27-year-old Canadian strategically exited government job to invest $38K pension commuted value, projecting $1M by 55 through self-directed investing versus accepting defined benefit pension—a bold move for generational wealth building.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Strong plan with clear math: converting $38K into LIRA/RRSP and matching $10K annual contributions mirrors pension contributions but builds $1M by 55 instead of locked-in pension. Good understanding of 4% withdrawal rule ($40K annually at 55) and tax-advantaged account strategy.
Areas to Focus
- • Define your current annual expenses and post-tax income from new employment. You need a concrete savings rate to ensure you can actually contribute $10K annually—this is the linchpin of your $1M projection.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Sequence of returns risk is real: market crash at 50-54 could devastate your 55 retirement date target. Also, pension offered survivor benefits (60% to spouse) while your portfolio's inheritance benefit is only realized if you/spouse die—unclear if that's the right trade-off for family security before 55.
The Original Post
I (27M) recently quit my government job after 5 years of service. The pension is considered the gold standard defined benefit pension plan. But it got me thinking - is it all that great? After 5 years of service, I contributed 26K, and the commuted value they're offering me is 28K, along with 10K worth of vacation credits, which I have to deposit into a LIRA (Locked-In Retirement Account, 28K) and an RRSP (Registered Retirement Savings Plan, 10K). If I worked with the government until 55, had an average best salary of 110K, contributed roughly 10K a year, I would've received approximately 60K a year for life starting at 55. Sounds pretty good. If I died, my spouse would get 60% of that as survivor benefit. Alternatively, what I decided to do is take that 38K and deposit it into my LIRA/RRSP. If I contribute 10K annually to match what I would've contributed annually to my pension, I would have roughly a $1M portfolio at 55 (assuming a 7% rate of return). If I follow a 4% rate ($40K annually) of withdrawal rule at 55, while the portfolio continues to grow 7%, by the time I'm 85, the portfolio would be $2.4M. At that point, whether myself or my spouse passes, our children would get a sizeable inheritance. In comparison, with a pension, your children get nothing. With this in mind, do you agree investing is better? There are risks, of course, you can get screwed over with terrible timing in regards to market crashes, but as someone who didn't receive any inheritance from my parents, this would be a great start and opportunity for generational wealth.