FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Is Backing Off the 401(k) and Starting a Roth the Best Move for This 28-Year-Old?

r/FinancialPlanning
10/13/2025
Age
28
Net Worth
$100,000
Income
$69,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 28 years old, this individual has been contributing to their 401(k) since age 20, building up a balance of $100,000. However, they're now looking to diversify their investments and potentially shift some focus to a Roth IRA for better tax advantages in retirement. With an annual salary of $69,000 and limited spare income, they're trying to determine the optimal investment strategy to maximize their FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) goals.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • This 28-year-old is already doing well by contributing 16% to their 401(k), including the company match. Building a $100,000 nest egg by age 28 puts them on a strong path towards FIRE.

Areas to Focus

  • • Consider opening a Roth IRA and contributing what you can, even if it's a small amount to start. This will provide additional tax-advantaged growth for retirement, as well as potential emergency access to your contributions if needed.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ With a relatively high savings rate but limited spare income, this individual may need to carefully balance their 401(k) and Roth IRA contributions to ensure they can still cover their day-to-day expenses. Closely monitoring their budget and cash flow will be important.

The Original Post

I'm 28 years old, I've been working with the same company since right at 20y/o and have been contributing at least enough since then to get full company match (6%). I'm at 10% now which puts me at 16% overall contributions and over 8 years, I now have a balance of around $100k (401k). The fund I've been contributing to is one that was automatically assigned to me (Blackrock Lifepath Index 2060K) through Empower (Thumbs down, I know). I've got my risk level set to extremely aggressive, but the fund is a moderate risk level fund. I'm now trying to diversify and get out of this fund, or at least mostly, as I realize my rate of return is around 20%, but I'm technically putting in 16%, so that's not a great return. (Just now realizing this) I've got a few funds I'm looking at to play with a little bit more risk, but my main question is now that I'm 28, would I be better off backing off to just get the company match and putting everything else into a Roth IRA? Starting the Roth IRA with very little funds will take a long time to grow, but inevitably be better at retirement age for tax purposes as well as the last resort emergency access. I don't have a lot of spare income and my annual salary is at the point that it just keeps me afloat. I'll share some of my finances below just to give a good snapshot of where I'm at. Annual salary: $69k (pre-tax, not including bonus as it's very market dependent) Savings: $19k (just sitting in a low yield savings account with my local bank. I know, I need to split this up to at least gain some interest) I've saved up a decent bit, but I'm not really making enough to add to savings, really just enough to pay bills and have a tad bit of money for other needed things. TLDR; Should I back off 401k and start a Roth IRA? Should I stick with 401k solely and just split my investments in higher-yielding funds?