FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Want to buy our dream home, but don't want to lose 2.875% rate on current home. Can we make it work?

r/FinancialPlanning
5/19/2024
Age
28
Net Worth
$304,000

Summary

The couple is in a strong financial position with a combined salary of $180k-$190k, $304,000 in net worth, and a low-interest mortgage on their current home. They are considering upgrading to a more expensive home, but after careful consideration, they have decided to remain in their current home to maintain their lifestyle and financial flexibility.

The Original Post

Four years ago, Reddit helped me make one of the best financial decisions I'll ever make. Well, we're coming up on another one, and I would love some feedback/advice. Back then, y'all encouraged my 23-year-old self to buy my first home. We ended up paying ~$210k for a terrific home that's now valued at ~$360k+ and an interest rate of 2.875%. I still work at the company, and several years later, my wife and I are doing really well. 3 days ago, we found a home in Zillow that's gorgeous and in a terrific neighborhood near downtown in our up-and-coming city (we're currently about 20 minutes out). It checks nearly all the boxes, and it's listed at $649,000. It's the kind of home I never thought I'd be able to afford - and I'm still not 100% sure if we can. But I think so? Quick stats Ages: We just turned 28/29 Combined Salary: ~$180k-190k (depending on bonuses and inconsistent freelance work). Savings: $101,000 in cash. ~$12k in a brokerage account. ~$191,000 in retirement accounts. 2 cars - paid off. Mine should be good for 8+ years. My wife will likely need to replace hers in a couple years. Kids aren't in the cards for us, so thankfully that's not a concern. Current home - mortgage payment is $1,200 monthly. Rental calculators online say that we should expect to get $1,600-$2,000 from it. Would likely go through a property management company. It's 4 years old and in solid shape. Avg. Monthly spending: $6,700-$7,000, including existing mortgage. We've been a little sloppy here, and could probably cut this down a bit. Monthly takehome - combined, I have us at around $12,125 monthly. If we adjust retirement contributions down to 15% each, then that jumps to $13k. Because we want to maintain an emergency fund, we only want to put around 10% down on the home. If you've read this far, I genuinely appreciate it. Specific questions: 1. Are we about to be house poor? By my numbers, I'm thinking we should still be saving around $1,500 a month with the new plan, but that is tighter than we've been. 2. Is it more efficient to use a 401k loan (or a HELOC on our existing home) for the other 10% of the downpayment? PMI (est. at $300/monthly) feels like throwing money away. Would also appreciate any other ideas here. 3. Lower interest rate aside, are we likely to save more in interest from selling our current home and applying the equity toward the new one? Or would it be better to rent it out, try to cut even on the mortgage, and maintain the equity/rate there? 4. I recognize that we've been privileged/blessed to be in a really good situation over the past few years. Any additional advice/concerns about the above? Anything I'm not considering? Thanks! 5/19 Edit: Thank you all so much for your thoughts and suggestions. After much consideration, my wife and I have decided to pass on the home. While we can technically afford it, the risk of carrying two mortgages and increased housing costs would impact our lifestyle too much. Even with selling our current home, we'd see our housing costs quadruple and it isn't worth losing that flexibility. We will stay in our current home, save more for a downpayment, and set up a Zillow notification for houses in that area at a price point that's a bit lower. We have been blessed with a cheap mortgage on a home we really like - and we're going to remain content with it for awhile longer while we wait for the right opportunity to come along.