FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

28-Year-Old with $320k Debates Taxable vs 401k: Is Early Access Worth It?

r/FinancialPlanning
12/5/2025
Age
28
Net Worth
$320,000
Income
$130,000/yr

Summary

28yo earning $130k with $320k net worth gets 24% total 401k contribution, maxes Roth IRA and HSA, questions taxable account strategy for home purchase.

The Original Post

Hi All, I’ve been handling my finances independently and believe I’m in a good spot but wanted to have a discussion and solicit feedback. For the past few years I’ve been making lots of contributions to my personal brokerage account with the thinking that I’ll want to use this money early on to buy a house and other short term goals. I feel I still have high enough contributions to my 401k but is this thinking foolish and should I just maximize 401k contributions instead? I’m 28yo with a salary of $130k. My 401k is at ~120k. Started and maxed a Roth IRA this year (and will continue to do so going forward. And personal brokerage account sitting at ~200k. I make an 8% contribution to my Roth 401k and my company makes a 16% profit sharing contribution on top of that to a traditional 401k. Additionally I will be maxing out my Roth IRA and HSA. An I foolish to continue contributing to my personal brokerage account rather than maxing out my 401k? Or do you think that my retirement savings/contributions across all other accounts are high enough that it’s reasonable to do this?