Should This 28-Year-Old Engineer Trade Private Sector Pay for Federal Stability?
- Age
- 28
- Net Worth
- $580,000
- Income
- $120,000/yr
- Profession
- Software Engineer
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 28 with $580k invested, this software engineer is weighing a return to federal work for a pension versus staying in a stagnant private role.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • With $580k already invested at 28, you have a massive head start that likely ensures long-term FI regardless of your near-term job choice.
Areas to Focus
- • Perform a side-by-side net present value calculation of the federal pension benefits versus private sector growth potential to make a data-driven career decision.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-focusing on immediate salary fluctuations instead of prioritizing long-term career growth or total compensation packages, including pension stability.
The Original Post
28yo software engineer. 580k invested. From 22yo-25yo I worked for the government making 80k. Contributed 3 years to a pension indexed to inflation. Its rule is after 25 years of work + being 60yo you can receive the pension without penalty. At 26yo I took a job offer in private for 140k and 5k retirement matching (its on NYSE). I knew in my second year salary would drop to 120k since I had a sign-on bonus, but I figured I’d still be making more than my old job and thought in my third year I’d be promoted to senior and earning around 170k (what the average senior makes). Fast forward 2.5 years I'm not senior, still making 120k, and the company has slashed salaries for new hires and is stalling promotions for myself and coworkers. I now have a job offer at my old federal job for 115k. While the salary is less than my current job, it’s got a pension. I’ve had candid talks with my manager who explains the earliest I’d see a promo (meaning raise) is Q1 2027 and even that is unlikely. Frankly, morale is low. Everyone knows the company is shrinking each year and its best days are behind it. The only upside I see is brand name and experience with modern technology for my resume. My plan has always been to grind and earn in private while younger then return to federal work for family life (e.g. 33-35yo) but that plan assumed private paid much more than federal which currently isn’t the case. The ideal scenario is finding a higher paying job in private but nobody is hiring right now. I also feel like if go back to government I'd stay at least a year which moves me closer to the coast age. What should I do?