FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Balancing $190k in Student Loans: Should I Sacrifice Retirement Savings to Debt?

r/FinancialPlanning
7/7/2026
Age
28
Net Worth
$58,500
Income
$102,000/yr
Expenses
$69,600/yr
Profession
LMFT
Location
HCOL city
FIRE Status
Behind

Summary

This 28-year-old therapist is working hard to balance $190k in debt with long-term retirement goals in a HCOL area.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You are doing great by maintaining a 401k match and consistent savings, which are essential building blocks.

Areas to Focus

  • • Prioritize aggressive repayment of the 7.6% interest loans as they are effectively guaranteed losses at that rate.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The high debt-to-income ratio combined with high cost-of-living expenses could lead to burnout or financial strain.

The Original Post

Hi folks! Feeling a bit buried by student loans and living in a HCOL city (that I love). Would love some advice on strategy here.  Age: 28, graduated from grad school in 2019 (I’m an LMFT) Living in a HCOL city  Income: variable, between 8-9k/month post-taxes from a W-2 job and sole proprietorship. About 6k of this is from my W-2, and 10% of it goes towards my 401k with a 4% match.  401k balance: $43,000 (I became eligible for it 2 years ago) Roth IRA balance: $15,500 HYS balance: $13,600 Credit card debt: A little high for the summer but generally minimal, gets paid off monthly  Expenses: $5,800/month (includes $1k to student loans, $583 to backdoor Roth IRA and $500 to HYS). The rest goes to fun money/eating out/travel/non-budgeted expenses Student Loans: $190k total in graduate and graduate plus loans with interest ranging from 4.3-7.6% Currently paying $1k/month towards highest interest loan as I am on the SAVE plan and on forbearance  I am considering redirecting all of my Roth IRA and HYS payments towards my student loans, but I feel deeply torn about this. I was so proud of the progress I was making on both of those fronts until I realized that the interest of my student loans was higher than the payoff. Would love some advice on how to best allocate my funds here or any other advice that comes to mind. Thanks in advance!