$600k Inheritance at 28: House vs Investments - The Dilemma Every Young FIRE Seeker Faces
- Age
- 28
- Net Worth
- $600,000
- Location
- Canada
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
Late 20s couple with $600k inheritance debating whether to pay cash for a house or invest it. Both have well-paying jobs and retirement accounts maxed.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You're already maxing out retirement and TFSA accounts which is excellent tax-advantaged investing. You're thinking mathematically about opportunity cost (mortgage rates vs investment returns). You have $600k liquid at 28 with well-paying jobs and minimal debt ($20k car loan only).
Areas to Focus
- • Put 20-25% down on the house ($120k-150k) and invest the remaining $450k+ in a diversified portfolio - this gives you housing stability while keeping your money working at higher expected returns than mortgage rates.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Tying up all $600k in a single illiquid asset (house) eliminates your financial flexibility and opportunity for compounding growth during your highest-earning years. A house doesn't generate cash flow and limits your ability to relocate for career opportunities or take advantage of market opportunities.
The Original Post
Me and my partner are in our late 20s and looking to buy a house in the near future. I have recently gotten an inheritance of \~$600,000 and I'm stuck on whether I should spend all/ most of it on a down payment for a house, or get a mortgage and keep a decent amount as investments. The inheritance/ income taxes are all solved, so that is the net amount. We have also already used as much as we could to max out both retirement and TFSA accounts. Other than a car loan, that has 20k left, there is no other debt or savings accounts that the money could go towards. We also both have well paying jobs, so eventually retiring is not that big of a worry. My issue is that I know if interest rates are lower than expected investment returns its 'generally' better to have the money invested. Also personally, it just 'feels' bad dumping all/ most of it into one purchase. However, if I can pay off all/ most of the mortgage debt outright, that also feels 'right' since we won't have that debt/ burden, or have it for long which is also good. I'm just looking for advice and experiences from others who know more/ have similar experiences. TL;DR - Should I spend all or most of an inheritance on a house, or spend less and keep more of it in investments.