FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

28-Year-Old With $137k in Assets, $77k in Debt: Pay Off Student Loans or Buy a House First?

r/FinancialPlanning
12/7/2025
Age
28
Net Worth
$60,000
Income
$94,000/yr
Profession
Salaried professional
Location
Northeast United States, near Boston
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

28-year-old earning $94k living with parents to save for a house, torn between crushing $60k student loan debt versus building down payment savings.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Maxing 401k at 28 puts you ahead of 90% of peers with $75k already saved. Living rent-free is saving you ~$1,500-2,000/month in expensive Boston area. Your $8,200 loan payment was smart - you eliminated high-interest debt while still maintaining $137k in assets.

Areas to Focus

  • • Stop scattered saving and laser-focus on the student loan - redirect your $800/month brokerage deposits plus rent savings ($2,000+/month) to pay off the $60k debt in under 2 years, then attack house savings with $3,000+/month.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Living with parents creates false sense of affordability - your $94k income won't stretch far with $1,235/month in debt payments plus Boston-area housing costs. Without knowing your true monthly expenses, you could be house-poor quickly after moving out.

The Original Post

I'm 28 year's old and have a salaried job making $94k before tax. I moved out of my apartment rental earlier this year (March) and have been living with my parents and saving on rent (I'm very thankful of them for this), ideally with the goal of purchasing some sort of property within the near-ish future. * **Savings:** \~$12k in stock holdings; \~$10k in a rolling CD; \~$75k in 401k (maxed contributions); $40k in managed brokerage account (I deposit $800 a month) * **Checking:** \~$8k between my checking and simple savings account which I use for normal expenses * **Debts:** $60k student loan (level payment plan; Direct; unsubsidized; $835/month); $17k auto loan ($400/month.) This is where I stand, I am unsure what the best thing to focus on going forward is. I'm not very confident in my savings strategy, I feel like I should pivot the money out of the CD and into something riskier or just straight into my student loan. I really want to crush this student loan away and save myself the $800/month. It's also tempting to just use all my savings resources to come up with the money to pay it off, then work on rebuilding those assets afterward. (whether that's from my stock, CD, 401k, or managed account idk) My goal of paying off my student loan is almost in opposition, yet ultimately towards my goal of purchasing a house. I don't feel secure enough to buy a house with my student loan looming over my head, but I also don't feel secure enough to buy a house if I deplete my invested savings, assuming buying a house is even possible for me right now. For context I live in the Northeast United States orbiting a long commute from Boston. Housing is pretty expensive. Is this urge to pay off my student loans warranted? Should that be my main focus right now if I also want to buy a house? Should I give up on the house (for now) and start looking for rentals while shifting my priority to loan repayment? I hope I was able to adequately portray my situation and the bugbear that's been sitting on my back about all this. For more context, before this post I impulsively scheduled an $8200 payment into my loan (dropping it from $68k to the \~$60k mentioned above) and am feeling a little crushed. Like was that a smart thing to do considering I could? There's still so much more that I owe.. What could I have done better with that money? I'm worried I'm making the wrong decisions and prolonging it all