Buying Our Forever Home at 29: Is a $3,500 Mortgage Payment Too Risky?
- Age
- 29
- Net Worth
- $140,000
- Income
- $160,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 29-year-old couple is transitioning from a starter home to a $535k historical property, questioning if the significant payment increase is a reasonable financial move.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a strong emergency fund and a manageable debt-to-income ratio, keeping your mortgage well below 35% of net income.
Areas to Focus
- • Increase your retirement savings rate from 12% to 15-20% to compensate for the higher housing costs.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ The high cost of maintaining a 1907 home with significant renovation needs could quickly drain your remaining liquid cash.
The Original Post
Ok backstory. We purchased our first home in 2021 at a 3% interest rate. It’s tiny, like less than 900 finished square feet over basement and two levels. Plus both bathrooms are bad. But we’ve had a $1,700 PITI payment which is pretty great. But we feel that we’ve really outgrown the house and need more space as we move into new phases in our life. We’ve been looking for about 2 years in our neighborhood which we love. But decided to look at a house out in a 1st-ring suburb the other week. It’s shockingly walkable. Two blocks from a grocery store, a cute downtown with restaurants and antique stores, etc. We love old homes with original woodwork and charm. This house ticked all those boxes. It’s a beautiful 1907 colonial with a three season porch and lovely woodwork. It’s been with one family for 4 generations. The house was originally listed in April with the extra lot next door at $850k. No one was interested. Then they re-listed in May splitting the lots and selling the house for $550k. The day we scheduled our showing they removed it from the market. The house has some issues. Not a very good kitchen, but we can live with it for a while. And also will need bathroom renovations at some point. Oh, and there will be new construction next door at some point when/if the vacant lot sells. It also is 100% knob and tube. After many rounds of negotiation, the sellers agreed to a purchase price of $535k and they will fully update all of the electrical in the house prior to close. We also have a sewer scope contingency. But the sewer and water lines were new as of 2025. We are putting 15% down \~$80k. Our estimated monthly PITI payment will be $3,547. Our net take home is $11,200 monthly. After purchasing we will have $60k in an emergency fund, $40k in investments, and $40k in 403b. We contribute 12% of gross income to pre-tax retirement monthly. We are 29, don’t have kids and don’t plan to at this point. I know someone is going to say our retirement is underfunded, but we are doing our best. I get tired of watching good houses slip away and just get more and more expensive every year. I guess my question is does this all seem reasonable? I’ve crunched the numbers so many times and we should be ok. But the change in monthly payment is so scary. When I heard our offer was accepted my stomach dropped. I expected to feel happy but I just feel scared. Trying to determine if it’s normal gitters or some gut feeling I should listen to.