Building vs. Moving: How a Healthcare Couple with $255k Net Worth Plans for Parenthood
- Age
- 29
- Net Worth
- $255,000
- Income
- $165,000/yr
- Expenses
- $60,000/yr
- Profession
- Healthcare
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This healthcare-focused couple is deciding between a home addition or relocating for their growing family. With $255k in net worth, they are well-positioned to balance lifestyle and FIRE goals.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You are saving $48,000 annually, which is excellent. Focus on maximizing tax-advantaged accounts to lower your taxable income before the transition to part-time work.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a detailed cost-benefit analysis comparing the $150k renovation versus the increased property taxes and potential commute costs of the second home option.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Transitioning to part-time work simultaneously with a child and a new mortgage could significantly reduce your compounding timeline; ensure your projected part-time income covers your new cost of living.
The Original Post
Fiancé 31M and I 29F are not sure which direction is better for our future. Staying put where we are and adding an addition to the current house, or purchasing a different house that meets our needs. We currently live in a 3 bed 1 bath, 1000 sqft house that I purchased shortly prior to meeting my partner. I kind of regret buying this house now, but that is a different story... I bought the house to reduce my monthly cost of living by approximately $500/mo and build equity. I planned to either add to it or move out eventually. Neighborhood is great, 10 minute work commute for both my fiancé and myself, but the house is small, lacks storage/garage/basement, and is not suitable for raising a family as is (very cramped bathroom, house overall needs some small improvements but is 100% livable for now, and is in good condition). House is currently valued at $204K and I have about $93K left on the mortgage with a rate of 6.875%. We have no debts between the two of us besides the mortgage. We have about $100K equity in the house, $55K cash savings, \~$100K each in 401K (mix of pretax and Roth, a few thousand each in taxable brokerages (recently opened, beginning to invest for potential early retirement, we just want more flexibility). My fiancé’s income is $41.00/hr and mine is $38.85/hr, so combined roughly $165K/yr pretax. Each month we save \~$4,000 (paying the minimum mortgage payment), more if we work some extra hours. Stable careers in healthcare industry. If we paid off the mortgage, we could save an additional $1000/mo. We are torn between two options for our future: 1) Building onto the current house to make it suitable for a potential family. Adding a garage, bedroom, bathroom, and storage. I could see us putting $150K into this house to make it comfortable. **Pros**: good neighbors, convenient location close to grocery and other stores, short work commutes, decent school district, low taxes compared to nearby zip codes ($4000 annual school/town), and I have several friends with very young children who live in the same district. I know if we did a home addition our taxes would increase dramatically, so I’m not sure if that really matters but for now it is nice. For example, a person owns an 1800 sqft 3 bed 3 bath home with a finished basement and attached garage, and they pay $9000 annual taxes. **Cons**: neighborhood has high ground water in spring, flooding is common in April/May months, slowly more and more homes are becoming rental properties for college students, and the front yard is very large compared to the backyard, in general we do not like to mow lawns we see it as a waste of resources. The house is on 1/2 acre and I have built a large garden in the backyard. Not sure what to do with the front yard. 2) Selling this house in 2-3 years and buying a house that meets our needs: 3-4 bed, 2 bath, basement, garage, 1300-1500 sqft. We are interested in houses like this in a different neighborhood in the same city, that offers more parks, playgrounds, and a beach within 10 minute walking distance. Houses in this neighborhood have been selling for $200K-$350K, depending on condition. **Pros**: great neighborhood for raising children, highly rated school district, manageable yard size (0.1-0.3 acres) typically much larger backyard and small front yard. Close to groceries and stores. Very few renters because it is not close to any colleges. There are some families with young children and many older couples and retirees in this neighborhood, so it is very quiet. I am biased because I lived by the water when I was young adult and I dreamed of raising my children near this location. My friends and their children would also love to visit to take walks to the beach and swim. I just see a wonderful and simple life in this neighborhood, compared to where we are at now. **Cons**: longer work commutes (25 minutes and 35 minutes), higher school/town taxes, usually around $7500-8500 combined annually. We plan to marry in May/June 2027, and have our first child in 2030. Both of us want to work part time while raising young children. Either path we take, the plan is to stay put and save+invest aggressively for the next 2-3 years so we can go part time (24 hours/week each) while raising children and hopefully stay part time until retirement. My fiancé may go back to work full time for a bit after the children are older, depending on our financial needs. We live pretty simply and just want to have our health and a roof over our heads, with some financial room to make weekend trips and occasional vacations. We mainly enjoy nature and cooking as our hobbies. My fiancé is leaning towards option 1, staying put and doing an addition on our current house, while I am leaning towards option 2, moving to the waterside town. We have likes and dislikes about both options. Does anybody have any insight? Do we follow emotions or finances more? We aren’t even sure if option 1 would be financially better in the long run. Either way, we live below our means and could work hard the next few years and then coast at part time and let compounding do its thing. We are torn. Did you follow the numbers or follow emotions, or both? Did you have any regrets? Have we even saved enough for this plan to work? Opinions, advice, and reflections appreciated!!