FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Young Family's $330K Dilemma: Keep the 2.125% Investment Property or Sell for Breathing Room?

r/FinancialPlanning
12/19/2025
Age
29
Net Worth
$330,000
Income
$139,200/yr
Expenses
$120,000/yr
Location
SE United States
FIRE Status
Behind

Summary

Married couple, age 29, with $330k net worth and combined $139k annual income are weighing whether to sell their out-of-state rental property ($330k value, $156k mortgage at 2.125%) to ease near-term cash flow strain or hold for long-term appreciation gains.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Strong early investing discipline: purchased rental property in early 20s with aggressive 15-year paydown and accumulated $160k in retirement accounts plus $174k home equity by age 29. Already planning significant savings increase with home purchase target in 2027 and new child in picture.

Areas to Focus

  • • Immediately stabilize cash flow by either (1) raising rental income to break-even minimum or (2) selling property if expenses exceed rental returns consistently. Currently spending 86% of gross income ($120k of $139k) which leaves minimal margin; need to increase that gap to accelerate brokerage investing and child education funding (529 barely started).

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-leveraged for their income stage: $156k mortgage on $330k property generating negative cash flow creates liquidity risk with new child expenses and upcoming home purchase (2027) competing for capital. Emergency fund of only $8k is dangerously low for a family with mortgage obligations and near-term expenses; this should be $20-25k minimum given their situation.

The Original Post

Hello looking for advice on our current financial situation. Married 29M & 29F. Just had our first child in November. Currently we are renting and own an out of state rental property. We had bought this property out of college and refinanced 1 time. In our early/mid 20s we looked at it as our main form of "investing" (renovations, aggressive payment for 15 year mortage) as we were not able to put much into other forms. Property is in a desirable area in a rapidly growing city in the SE and should continue to increase in value. I do believe we are behind on savings/investing front for our age and we are planning to increase our efforts here. We will be renting until 2027 and then will be planning to purchase a home. We are considering selling the out of state property due to several reasons: * Large near term expenses that we are expecting. * The logistical challenges of managing it from out of state. * After expenses we do not break even on the property so it is challenging our budget in the short term. We are conflicted on this due to the favorable interest rate that we have. Is it best to tough it out in the short term for the long term gain? Or sell and use the income to shore up our financial situation? **Income:** * Combined $11,600 after taxes * Additional $1,950 in rental income, including separately. **Expenses:** * \~$10k/mo * Additional $1,890 for mortgage and HOA dues, including separately. **Net Worth Breakdown:** * Retirement: \~$160K * Brokerage Account: \~$13K * Home Equity: \~174$K * Emergency Fund: $8K * 529: $1K (Just started, including to show as option for income from selling the property) * UGMA: Plan to start soon, including to show as option for income from selling the property **Property Info:** * Remaining Mortgage: \~$156K * Interest Rate: 2.125% * Estimated Value: \~$330K * Term: 15 years, 11 remaining