Buying a $650k Starter Home on $475k Income: Being Too Conservative or Just Smart?
- Age
- 30
- Net Worth
- $1,600,000
- Income
- $475,000/yr
- Profession
- Software Engineer
- Location
- MCOL city
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 30-year-old couple in Big Tech has a $1.6M net worth and is choosing a sensible starter home to protect their financial future despite qualifying for much more.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Your decision to size your mortgage to potential future income rather than current peak earnings is a prudent hedge against tech volatility and life changes.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a sensitivity analysis on your long-term savings rate assuming one partner transitions to part-time work to ensure your FIRE timeline remains intact.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-optimizing for frugality might lead to transaction cost friction; ensure the house quality supports your quality of life goals for the next decade.
The Original Post
30M/30F, MCOL city, no kids yet (planning in 1-2 years). Renters our whole lives until now. * Income: \~$450-500k combined (me $275-325k big tech, her $175k). Software side business does \~$8-10k/mo profit, not counted in above. * NW \~$1.6MM: $700k taxable, $600k retirement, $300k HYSA. No debt, paid off her \~$175k of grad school loans a couple years ago. * Just went under contract at $650k, 25% down. 4bd/3ba in a good neighborhood. Could pay it off in cash if we had to. We'd be approved for $1.5MM+. We didn't go near that, and I keep second-guessing it. Case for the starter house: our income is at its peak right now and probably won't stay here. Wife likely drops to 2-3 days/week once we have kids. My big tech job is not a 20-year plan between layoff cycles and AI reshaping the role. Sizing the house to $250-300k of expected future income feels more honest than sizing it to what we make today. Case for stretching: we'll likely outgrow this in 7-10 years (spacious split level, \~3,100 sq ft, but 2x car garage and split-level aspect makes it feel a bit smaller than it is on paper), so we're signing up for a second set of transaction costs and possibly weaker appreciation. The next tier at $900k-1.2MM gets us into actual dream territory, on a lake in the best case. But with kids arriving in the next 1-2 years, I don't know how much we'd use that space or that lake until they're old enough to make memories there. Questions for anyone who's been here: 1. Bought the sensible starter, then traded up 7-10 years later - did the double transaction cost you more than stretching once would have, or did the flexibility pay for itself? 2. Stretched near the top of your approval and then had income drop (layoff, spouse going part-time)? How bad was it actually? 3. Is buying at \~1.4x gross conservative, or just correct when your gross could be temporarily inflated? 4. Big tech folks - has the last two years changed how you size housing, or is that overthinking it? Genuinely open to hearing from anyone who have been in a similar situation!