30-Year-Old Union Worker Seeking Clarity: Roth 457 vs Traditional Deferred Comp
- Age
- 30
- Net Worth
- $30,000
- FIRE Status
- Behind
Summary
With $30k saved across three retirement accounts after four years, this 30-year-old state employee is evaluating the tax efficiency of their Roth contributions compared to traditional plans.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Leveraging a union pension, 401k match, and Roth 457 shows a solid foundation for long-term retirement planning.
Areas to Focus
- • Create a detailed monthly budget to identify where money is leaking, as you are currently living paycheck to paycheck despite your contributions.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Relying on future income increases to reach retirement goals while ignoring current cash flow deficits can lead to long-term financial instability.
The Original Post
Hopefully I can give enough info for you to be able to help me. So I work for the state I live in. I currently make $22.57 an hour with a decent amount of OT and consistent pay raises due to being in the union. I “technically” have 3 retirements. I have a “Hybrid Pension” which is a partial pension and a 401k where my company matches 2.5% of said 401k. I put a mandated 5% into my pension and 3.25% in my 401k with the employer 2.5% match. I also am enrolled in my company’s deferred compensation plan which is a Roth 457 so it’s a traditional deferred comp plan and a Roth (before tax and after tax). The plan started as 2% into both the before tax and after tax. The pension and 401k are the same but I have since moved my percentage from 2% towards each and changed into just 4% into the Roth where it takes the taxes out now rather than at retirement withdraw. I have been at the company for almost 4 years now and have roughly $30k combined in all three of these accounts. My wife (35) and I (30) live paycheck to paycheck and I can’t put in even close to the full yearly amount allotted for retirement plans. My question is about my thinking towards putting 4% into the Roth rather than traditional. I figured since I’m not making that much that I’m paying less in taxes now than I will be whenever I retire since I’ll be in a higher tax bracket then so that’s why it makes more sense to put into the Roth. Am I wrong in that thinking? I appreciate any advice in advance! My wife has her own retirement as well so this is more just of a question for myself rather than for both of us.