FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

30-Year-Old Union Worker Seeking Clarity: Roth 457 vs Traditional Deferred Comp

r/FinancialPlanning
8/24/2026
Age
30
Net Worth
$30,000
FIRE Status
Behind

Summary

With $30k saved across three retirement accounts after four years, this 30-year-old state employee is evaluating the tax efficiency of their Roth contributions compared to traditional plans.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Leveraging a union pension, 401k match, and Roth 457 shows a solid foundation for long-term retirement planning.

Areas to Focus

  • • Create a detailed monthly budget to identify where money is leaking, as you are currently living paycheck to paycheck despite your contributions.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Relying on future income increases to reach retirement goals while ignoring current cash flow deficits can lead to long-term financial instability.

The Original Post

Hopefully I can give enough info for you to be able to help me. So I work for the state I live in. I currently make $22.57 an hour with a decent amount of OT and consistent pay raises due to being in the union. I “technically” have 3 retirements. I have a “Hybrid Pension” which is a partial pension and a 401k where my company matches 2.5% of said 401k. I put a mandated 5% into my pension and 3.25% in my 401k with the employer 2.5% match. I also am enrolled in my company’s deferred compensation plan which is a Roth 457 so it’s a traditional deferred comp plan and a Roth (before tax and after tax). The plan started as 2% into both the before tax and after tax. The pension and 401k are the same but I have since moved my percentage from 2% towards each and changed into just 4% into the Roth where it takes the taxes out now rather than at retirement withdraw. I have been at the company for almost 4 years now and have roughly $30k combined in all three of these accounts. My wife (35) and I (30) live paycheck to paycheck and I can’t put in even close to the full yearly amount allotted for retirement plans. My question is about my thinking towards putting 4% into the Roth rather than traditional. I figured since I’m not making that much that I’m paying less in taxes now than I will be whenever I retire since I’ll be in a higher tax bracket then so that’s why it makes more sense to put into the Roth. Am I wrong in that thinking? I appreciate any advice in advance! My wife has her own retirement as well so this is more just of a question for myself rather than for both of us.