FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Should We Buy a $1.3M Condo or Maximize Our Rent-Stabilized Lifestyle in Queens?

r/HENRYfinance
10/27/2026
Age
30
Net Worth
$400,000
Income
$400,000/yr
Expenses
$36,000/yr
Location
Queens, NY
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This high-earning couple in Queens is evaluating the long-term trade-offs between their rent-stabilized apartment and purchasing a $1.3M condo as they plan for future family growth.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Leveraging a rent-stabilized unit while keeping $400k in cash is a strong capital-preservation strategy that allows for significant market compounding.

Areas to Focus

  • • Perform a rigorous break-even analysis on the $1.3M purchase, specifically factoring in the opportunity cost of the $400k down payment if invested in the market at a 7% return.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-leveraging into a high-interest rate mortgage for a primary residence may significantly tighten cash flow and limit flexibility for the upcoming life change of having a child.

The Original Post

First-time poster here. My partner (30F) and I (30M) have a combined gross income of \~$400k, split roughly 50/50. We’ve lived in Queens for the past 8 years and are trying to figure out whether buying a condo in the next few years makes financial sense, or whether we’d be better off continuing to rent. We have no debt, and \~$400k available for a down payment and closing costs **Our current housing situation and plans** We currently pay $3,000/month for a rent-stabilized 1BR in Queens. Our lease situation will continue to hold rent stabilization for 5 more years, and a 2BR in our current building rents for roughly $4,500 today. We plan to have one child in about 3 years and intend to stay in the NYC area long-term, due to our jobs and my partner’s family in Queens. Eventually, we’ll need more space, but we don’t necessarily need to move immediately. **The purchase we’re considering** We’ve been looking at 2BR/2BA condos in Queens for approximately $1.3M–$1.4M, with monthly property taxes and common charges totaling around $1,500–$2,000. With \~$400k down, I estimate our total monthly ownership cash outlay at roughly $8,500, including principal, interest, taxes, and common charges. I estimate the after-tax cost could be closer to $6,800 post-deductions. Assuming a 2bd is around $5,000 and excluding mortgage principal from the calculation (which I’m currently viewing as just a forced savings), the incremental economic cost of owning at around $1,000/month. One thing to note is that one of use drives to work (garage needed) and the other needs to be within walking distance of the subway. This unfortunately restricts the number of buildings we can look at in our desired neighborhoods.  **The question** If we know we want to stay in NYC and will likely need a 2BR in the next few years, does it make sense to buy now and start building equity/lock in housing costs, or are we better off keeping our rent-stabilized apartment for as long as possible and revisiting homeownership closer to when we have a child (if ever)? For those who have modeled this or faced a similar decision, how would you approach the rent-versus-buy comparison? Are there assumptions in my math that you’d challenge, particularly around tax benefits, opportunity cost, and the holding period needed to make buying worthwhile? Edit: there’s a lot of comments here on rent-stabilization so I want to take a moment to clarify. RS is not affordable housing and does not have any income limitations or lottery. It is also different from rent control, and all RS does is cap how much rent can increase each year during occupancy. Meaning the moment somebody moves out of an RS unit, the rent will be calibrated to the current market rate. My current rate will not be transferred to the next tenant. Whether or not this is good economic policy is a separate debate, but there’s no “gaming of the system” here.