FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Paying Off a 5.875% Mortgage vs. Investing: A 30-Year-Old's Dilemma

r/FinancialPlanning
9/19/2026
Age
30
Net Worth
$564,000
Income
$270,000/yr
Expenses
$94,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 30, this couple earns $270k with strong pension prospects and $300k invested. They are weighing whether to prioritize paying down their $636k mortgage or continuing to invest for FIRE.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You are doing excellent work by maxing retirement accounts and maintaining dual pensions. With a 5.875% mortgage rate, your plan to pay it down provides a guaranteed return.

Areas to Focus

  • • Calculate your total target FIRE number including the future value of your pensions to see if your current savings rate is sufficient to offset the lost market gains of prepaying the debt.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Opportunity cost of capital: by prioritizing a 5.875% mortgage over long-term index fund growth, you may miss out on significant compounding over the next 7-12 years.

The Original Post

I will be turning 30 next week. I currently make about 170k a year. I invest 20% into 401k/457/roth and have done this since 22. I have about 300k currently. In addition to this I have a defined pension plan that will allow me to retire at 42 and is equal to 70k a year. I own a townhome which has a 2.625 rate. It is rented out and cashflows. I have zero interest in paying it off. In addition to that, my primary residence was financed last year. The current loan amount is 636k and my rate is 5.875. The payment comes out to 4340 a month and we are making payments of 4600 to pay just a little more. My wife makes about 100k a year and also has a defined pension. Her benefit will be 60k and we can retire the same time. As I look at our future, I know that a true retirement with our house payment could be hard. So I’d like to get it paid for so we actually have the ability to retire young. We do have a young family so who knows if we will act on retiring so young but I want it to be an option. We may go find different fields and continue to work. I’m just know I don’t want to be one of the guys who can’t leave due to bills. In regards to our home, we paid 810k for it. It’s was/is a fixer upper and finished it’s probably worth 1.2 million. Not there yet as it’s dated. We have it to a spot where it’s definitely livable but just not modern. My wife wants to update the home but I look at it as the kids are young and will damage things quickly if we were to put a new kitchen in and do the other things she wants. I have about 1300 a week of disposable cash after everything. We have a good budget and stick to it. I am in the mindset of putting all of that towards the house as our rate is high and having the house paid off would create freedom for us. Doing this for 7ish years would pay off the house and save us so much in interest. She is okay with it but argues it would be better to invest the money. I do understand the logic but freedom of bills is worth a lot in my mind. What do you guys believe the smart move would be?