30-Year-Old Earning $165k Drowning in Savings Options: Retirement or House First?
- Age
- 30
- Net Worth
- $68,000
- Income
- $165,000/yr
- Expenses
- $48,000/yr
- Profession
- Healthcare/Government (PSLF eligible)
- Location
- High cost of living state
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
30-year-old earning $165k with $68k net worth (after $140k student loans) questioning if aggressive retirement saving should pause for homeownership.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Crushing retirement contributions at $47k+/year across 401k, 457b, HSA, and Roth while maintaining aggressive 28% savings rate. Smart PSLF strategy could eliminate $140k in loans tax-free in ~7.5 years. Already accumulated $173k in retirement assets just 2.5 years post-graduation - exceptional velocity.
Areas to Focus
- • Stop the 457B contributions ($23k/year freed up) immediately to accelerate house down payment - you're over-saving for a 58-60 retirement age and the non-governmental 457b carries creditor risk that isn't worth delaying homeownership another 5+ years.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Non-governmental 457b exposes $30k+ to employer bankruptcy risk while simultaneously preventing you from building home equity in your 30s - you're trading guaranteed housing cost increases and life flexibility for marginal tax optimization on a 30-year timeline.
The Original Post
Hi All, Long time lurker. I have been recently contemplating my current savings plan. Currently live in high cost of living state with state taxes. My stats below: Gross income \~$165,000 (graduated 2.5 years prior) 401K: $110,000 (max yearly, with \~5% MBDR contributions) 457B (non-governmental): $30,000 (first year maxing account) HSA: $12,000 (max yearly) Roth: $21,000 (max yearly) Student Loans: $140,000 (planning PSLF) Savings: $35,000 Take home pay: $2,500/pay period Monthly Spend: \~$4,000 (including rent, utilities, food, etc) My goal is to retire around 58-60 years old giving me 28-30 more working years. I'd like to start saving for a house and am able to save about $800-1000/month with current take home pay, while still enjoying life. Currently paying $0/month to student loans given the SAVE plan fiasco, though would anticipate a payment of \~$800/month (haven't figured out the actual math with the new plans though this is what similar colleagues pay with similar loan amounts). I fully acknowledge that I will likely have to pull back on some retirement savings when student loans start up again and would like to optimize my payments by also shielding some of my taxable income in pre-tax accounts to lower my monthly payments. Givin current housing costs and interest rates, it seems like a big uphill battle to save for a house. At this point, I am wondering if it would be better to pull back on retirement savings (e.g. stop contributing to 457B or MBDR) to save for a house or my current plan is sustainable and reasonable for a house with a goal to obtain one in the next 10 years? Any thoughts, advice or discussion is appreciated!