Software Engineer at 30: Should I Ditch My MFD for DIY or a Fee-Only RIA?
- Age
- 30
- Net Worth
- $7,000,000
- Profession
- Software Engineer
- Location
- Bengaluru
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 30, this software engineer has built a ₹70L+ portfolio over 8 years and is now debating switching from a commission-based distributor to a more cost-effective DIY or fee-only advisor model.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Your 13-14% XIRR is solid, but high commissions on ₹65L are eating your long-term compounding.
Areas to Focus
- • Consult a fee-only SEBI-registered investment advisor to transition to direct funds and simplify your 14-fund portfolio.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Your current portfolio is heavily skewed (55-60%) toward small-cap and momentum funds, exposing you to significant volatility.
The Original Post
Background: 30, software engineer in Bengaluru. I've been investing in mutual funds for about 8 years, almost entirely through a mutual fund distributor (regular plans). To be fair to him, having an MFD kept me investing consistently all these years. Where I am now: \- Corpus \~₹70L+, XIRR around 13–14% \- 14+ funds across 13 AMCs, very small-cap heavy (\~55–60% in small-cap/momentum funds) \- Several recent picks he suggested (momentum funds, newer small-cap funds) are only \~+10% after 2 years \- Last year I started a separate direct-plan track on Groww (Nifty 50 index, Midcap 150 index, PPFAS Flexi Cap, Gold FoF) \- He's now pitching a new small-cap NFO, saying valuations are "like COVID". But the Smallcap 250 PE is \~34–36 vs a 5-year median of \~28, so I'm skeptical. My problem: I want better returns (I understand the risk), but my job is demanding and I can't spend time tracking funds. That's why I went with an MFD. But regular-plan commission on \~₹65L is probably ₹40–60K every year, and it compounds. Questions: 1. Is 13–14% XIRR over 8 years reasonable for a small-cap-heavy portfolio, or am I underperforming the index? 2. For someone with no time: MFD (regular plans) vs fee-only SEBI RIA vs a simple DIY index portfolio. What did you pick and why? 3. Anyone using AI tools (ChatGPT/Claude) for portfolio reviews long term? How much do you trust that vs a human with 20 years of experience? 4. If I move regular → direct, how do you handle exit load and LTCG when shifting a large corpus? Thanks in advance!