FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Software Engineer at 30: Should I Ditch My MFD for DIY or a Fee-Only RIA?

r/leanfire
10/19/2026
Age
30
Net Worth
$7,000,000
Profession
Software Engineer
Location
Bengaluru
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 30, this software engineer has built a ₹70L+ portfolio over 8 years and is now debating switching from a commission-based distributor to a more cost-effective DIY or fee-only advisor model.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Your 13-14% XIRR is solid, but high commissions on ₹65L are eating your long-term compounding.

Areas to Focus

  • • Consult a fee-only SEBI-registered investment advisor to transition to direct funds and simplify your 14-fund portfolio.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Your current portfolio is heavily skewed (55-60%) toward small-cap and momentum funds, exposing you to significant volatility.

The Original Post

Background: 30, software engineer in Bengaluru. I've been investing in mutual funds for about 8 years, almost entirely through a mutual fund distributor (regular plans). To be fair to him, having an MFD kept me investing consistently all these years. Where I am now: \- Corpus \~₹70L+, XIRR around 13–14% \- 14+ funds across 13 AMCs, very small-cap heavy (\~55–60% in small-cap/momentum funds) \- Several recent picks he suggested (momentum funds, newer small-cap funds) are only \~+10% after 2 years \- Last year I started a separate direct-plan track on Groww (Nifty 50 index, Midcap 150 index, PPFAS Flexi Cap, Gold FoF) \- He's now pitching a new small-cap NFO, saying valuations are "like COVID". But the Smallcap 250 PE is \~34–36 vs a 5-year median of \~28, so I'm skeptical. My problem: I want better returns (I understand the risk), but my job is demanding and I can't spend time tracking funds. That's why I went with an MFD. But regular-plan commission on \~₹65L is probably ₹40–60K every year, and it compounds. Questions: 1. Is 13–14% XIRR over 8 years reasonable for a small-cap-heavy portfolio, or am I underperforming the index? 2. For someone with no time: MFD (regular plans) vs fee-only SEBI RIA vs a simple DIY index portfolio. What did you pick and why? 3. Anyone using AI tools (ChatGPT/Claude) for portfolio reviews long term? How much do you trust that vs a human with 20 years of experience? 4. If I move regular → direct, how do you handle exit load and LTCG when shifting a large corpus? Thanks in advance!