FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Expecting Parents Weighing a $650k Home Upgrade: Prudence or Regret in the Making?

r/coastFIRE
8/1/2026
Age
31
Net Worth
$410,000
Income
$331,000/yr
Location
Midwest, US
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This couple is balancing a $410k portfolio and high combined income with the decision to upgrade their home before their first child arrives.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You are currently saving 20% of your income toward investments and have proactively built a $30k buffer for mortgage increases.

Areas to Focus

  • • Run a detailed cash-flow projection that includes potential childcare costs and the lower income from a possible part-time transition.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-leveraging with a 6.3% mortgage rate while entering a high-expense life phase with a new baby could reduce your financial flexibility.

The Original Post

Husband is 33, I'm 31, and we're expecting our first. We're in a privileged spot financially and I know that, but I still feel like I'm too close to this decision to see it clearly, so I'd love to hear from anyone who's been through something similar. Some numbers on us: he earns $100k plus a $15k bonus, I earn $156k with bonus potential up to 25%. We each put 20% of our income toward investments and we're sitting at $170k (him) and $240k (me) invested, both tracking toward Coast FIRE. No debt besides the mortgage, full emergency funds each, a separate fund for when our beater cars finally die, and $10k set aside for a couple vacations a year. We bought our current place in 2019 for $275k with 10% down. It's a 1950s house in a decent, but not great neighborhood, not great schools either, in a major US city in the midwest. We were 23 and 25 when we bought it and went pretty conservative, which felt smart at the time but honestly I regret it a little now given how our incomes grew (If we had stretched then, we may not even feel the need to move now). We've put real work into it since, new roof, pulled all the old knob and tube wiring, remodeled the main bathroom, added some recessed lighting, painted the whole thing inside and out. Mortgage is $1,909 a month at 3.375%. We passed 20% equity a while back and dropped PMI, and our realtor thinks conservatively we could sell for $360k, which would net us around $90k after everything's paid off. About two years ago we started setting aside an extra $1,632 a month specifically to get used to the idea of a bigger mortgage payment, and that's grown into a $30k fund. Combined with the sale proceeds we'd have roughly $120k to put down on whatever comes next. Our credit is 800+ both of us, so the bank would obviously hand us more than we should actually take. We started casually looking at houses around the time we found out I was pregnant, and a financial therapist we talked to (she mostly works with people trying to get out of debt) told us $650k was a reasonable number for our situation. Then we actually found a place at that price. It's further out from the city center though, and has a $63 monthly HOA. Our lender quoted us 6.3% on the rate. Here's my actual conflict: I go back and forth between thinking we've got baby-house fever and are about to make ourselves house poor right when our expenses are changing the most, versus thinking we're about to repeat the same overly cautious move we made in 2019 and we'll be sitting here in five years wishing we'd bought while we had the equity and the income to do it. Staying put keeps things flexible, it would be a lot easier for me to stay home for a while or go part time after the baby's born if we're not carrying a much bigger payment. But I've wanted a genuinely well designed home, since I was a kid, and part of me feels like that's worth stretching for. Has anyone bought at a real stretch price point while pregnant or right after having a kid? Did it work out, or do you wish you'd waited? What didn't you think about going in that you wish someone had told you? Am I missing something obvious here or just talking myself into what I already want to do? Help me see my blind spots.