FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

32-Year-Old Salesman with $660k Net Worth Faces $170k Decision: Rental or Market?

r/Fire
12/20/2025
Age
32
Net Worth
$660,000
Income
$330,000/yr
Expenses
$84,000/yr
Profession
Sales
Location
Middle cost of living area, US (low tax state)
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

32-year-old married salesman earning $330k with $660k net worth and $84k annual expenses is deciding whether to keep his first home as a rental (projected $950/mo positive cash flow) or liquidate $170k equity for his new $595k home.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Strong income-to-expense ratio ($330k income vs $84k expenses = 75% savings rate), excellent debt discipline (only mortgage, no other debt), and strategic real estate positioning with a highly favorable 3.5% rate on the rental property that's difficult to replicate today.

Areas to Focus

  • • Clarify the true rental income projections—$2k/month gross leaves only $950/month after the $1,050 mortgage, but factor in property management (8-12%), maintenance reserves (1% annually), vacancy rates (5%), and taxes/insurance to confirm actual cash flow. This rental may be cash-flow negative in reality, which would strain liquidity.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-leveraging with dual mortgages ($595k new home at 10% down = $535.5k financed + $130k existing) while relying entirely on volatile sales income creates concentration risk. If income drops or rental doesn't perform as projected, he's exposed with only $110k emergency reserves covering ~1.5 months of expenses.

The Original Post

Pretty much as the title says, I'm getting under contract for a new primary residence, and thinking of keeping my current house to rent it out. A few details: 32M \- Married with 3-kids \- Wife stays home with the kids (she is a saint) \- Income is $330k +/- (in sales, so it varies slightly year to year) - before taxes \- Middle cost of living area in the US (low tax state) \- Current house bought for $191k in 2019 on 3.5% interest at 10% down \- Value estimate is $300k ($130k left on the loan) \- All in monthly payment including escrow is $1,050 \- Monthly expenses are around $7k/mo all in (including mortgage) \- $110k cash saved in the bank \- $550k stocks/ETFs (combined brokerage & IRAs) \- No debt outside of the house New House: \- $595k purchase price \- All in monthly payment including escrow will be $3,517/mo \- Putting 10% down \- Selling is covering all closing cost **Does it make sense to keep my old house and rent it out?** \- Local Comps (according to Zillow and Redfin) put its rental potential around $2k/mo \- This leaves about $950 per month in margin \- There isn't much work that needs to be done to the house, we just put a new roof on it, interior is all updated, we have one more project to do, but after that, its all set It feels wrong to give up this house, it was such a great buy at the time with the interest rate and price. However, should I sell it, take the $170k equity and put it in this house or just dump it into the markets. Anyone have any experience with this?