San Diego Home: Sell or Rent Out (and Possibly Reinvest in Multiple Properties)?
- Age
- 32
- Net Worth
- $670,000
Summary
The poster is a 32-year-old married entrepreneur with a new baby, who is considering selling their San Diego home worth $1.4M with a $600k mortgage, or keeping it as a rental property, in order to move closer to financial independence. They have a sizable net worth of $670k invested in crypto, stocks, and savings, and are weighing the pros and cons of retaining the property for appreciation or diversifying into multiple rental properties in the Midwest.
The Original Post
Hey FI community! I’m 32, married with a new baby, and I’ve been an entrepreneur for 12 years. I’m relocating from San Diego to Chicago and debating whether to sell my primary home or keep it as a rental—with my ultimate goal being to **move closer to financial independence**. Here are the details: • **San Diego Home** • Bought 5 years ago for $1M; current value around $1.4M • Remaining mortgage: $600k at 3.5% fixed (\~$4,300/month PITI) • Potential rental income: $5,700–$6,000/month → small monthly surplus if I self-manage from Chicago • **If I Sell** • Likely net around $750k after mortgage and closing costs • Qualify for significant capital gains exclusion (married, lived here 5 years) • Could invest that $750k in other assets (though cautious about market volatility) • Might also pick up multiple $200k-ish properties in the Midwest to boost cash flow • **Current Finances** • Annual income: $120k from my business (I’d like to grow this) • Savings breakdown: • $400k in crypto • $150k in stocks • $40k cash • $80k in a HYSA • Will be **renting** in Chicago for now, uncertain how long • **Main Dilemma (FI Perspective)** 1. **Retain the SD property** for appreciation and a locked-in 3.5% rate, gradually building equity as I pursue FI. But it means long-distance landlording—and I’m already busy with a newborn and my business. 2. **Sell and diversify** into other investments or more affordable rental properties with better cash flow, potentially accelerating my FI timeline if the returns outpace holding a single high-value property. 3. I’m aware **no one can predict markets**, but I’d love to hear how folks in this community approached similar decisions when balancing a high-value property vs. multiple cash-flow rentals vs. stock/crypto investments on their FI journeys. • **Lifestyle Considerations** • My wife and I have a new baby, so time and stress management matter a lot. • I can self-manage from afar or hire a property manager; either way, there’s a learning curve and extra overhead. • Eventually, I might start another venture or invest in something else, but probably not for another 1–2 years. **If you’ve managed out-of-state rentals while pursuing FI, or sold a high-equity home to accelerate your path, I’d love your input.** Any suggestions or cautionary tales about building a real estate portfolio for FI would be hugely appreciated! Thank you in advance.