Should I Pay 0.33% in Fees to Save My Backdoor Roth Strategy at 32?
- Age
- 32
- Net Worth
- $720,000
- Income
- $95,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 32, this investor is weighing the cost of 401k fees against the long-term benefit of keeping a backdoor Roth strategy viable while managing a $720k portfolio.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Maintaining a $720k portfolio at age 32 is excellent progress. Your focus on tax optimization and future-proofing your backdoor Roth is a sophisticated approach to long-term wealth.
Areas to Focus
- • Evaluate if the 0.33% fee outweighs the tax benefits of a potential future backdoor Roth by calculating the breakeven point based on your expected income growth.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-optimizing for a hypothetical future income bracket while currently eroding your net worth with avoidable plan fees.
The Original Post
I'm 32 and make about $95k base. I’m trying to decide where to rollover $120k from my ESOP. I found out recently that my 401k now charges new plan fees which totals to about 0.33% of my full balance every year (\~0.25% plan fees + 0.08% fund). This news really blindsided me since up until now, the only expense from my 401k was from the target date fund, at least to my knowledge. I have a significant amount in my account which makes these fees look pretty steep. It’s about 2k with my current balance of $600k, and it would be about $400 more each year if I roll in the other $120k from the ESOP. That’s not including my contributions from my paychecks. In comparison, a zero-expense Fidelity fund in an IRA would have cost nothing. I have done rollovers in the past into my 401k with my current employer— partly to keep pre-tax money out of the IRA so the pro-rata rule wouldn't wreck a future backdoor Roth if my income ever becomes high enough to be ineligible for direct Roth contributions. I hope that my income increases down the line, but I don’t actually know for certain if I will ever pass that threshold (I believe the current limit is $168k), and now I’m starting to second guess the decision to roll that money into my 401k and paying these additional fees as a result. Would you pay 0.33% each year to keep a backdoor option open even if you may never need it? Do you think this expense is high for an employer sponsored 401k?