From High Earner to Firefighter: Why 33-Year-Old's $316K Portfolio Has Calculators Disagreeing on Coast FIRE
- Age
- 33
- Net Worth
- $316,000
- Income
- $72,500/yr
- Expenses
- $75,000/yr
- Profession
- Firefighter
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 33 with $316k invested, this firefighter successfully transitioned from tech to meaningful work while maintaining strong retirement savings. Planning for coast FIRE at age 60-62 with pension and social security backup makes his path more secure than calculators suggest.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Smart diversification with $316k across S&P 500, large cap, and international ETFs at age 33. Contributing $1,100/month to retirement accounts shows disciplined savings despite career pivot. Dual income sources (pension + Social Security) provide multiple revenue streams most investors don't have.
Areas to Focus
- • Clarify your actual retirement spending assumption: Is $75k your current lifestyle or projected retirement spend? The discrepancy between calculators often stems from unclear withdrawal rates (4% vs 3%) and pension assumptions. Get a formal pension estimate in writing from your employer—this could reduce your needed portfolio by $200k-400k depending on pension value.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-reliance on uncertain future income streams (pension + Social Security) while underestimating inflation impact. Pending life changes (kids in 2 years) will significantly reduce your $1,100/month contributions when you likely need them most. Also, not having a documented retirement expense number means you're flying blind on coast FIRE status.
The Original Post
What coast fire calculators do y'all recommend using? I googled it and plugged my # into 8-10 calculators, and half said congrats, you've reached coast fire, the other 1/2 were saying bro you've got a long way to go. Also, how do y'all calculate expected expenditure in retirement? I'm using $75k a year but I dunno. Bradybolton, portseido, and clark all say I'm there. Walletburst, coastfirecalc, marriagekidsand money all say I'm far from my goal. 33 yo, planning retirement 60-62 yo, was high earner ($115k/year) but quit to become a firefighter and now make $65-80k / year depending on how much OT & side gig work I do. I will have a pension from firefighting and as I worked private industry for 10 years, will have social security too (if it's still around). I don't know how much to rely on either of those revenue streams as neither are guaranteed (pension should be but I don't trust anyone and anything can be mismanaged). Currently have $316k in brokerage & retirement accounts, mostly invested in S&P500, large cap, and international ETFs. Am contributing \~$1100 / month to my 401k/457b, but once I have kids (probably in a couple years) I might have to drop that considerably. How do I know when I'll have made it to coast?