Is a 1.6% AUM Fee Worth It? My Struggle Diversifying a $314k Concentrated Portfolio
- Age
- 33
- Net Worth
- $466,000
- Income
- $220,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 33 with a $466k net worth, I'm weighing whether to pay a 1.6% advisory fee to restructure my concentrated $314k portfolio or go DIY with a tax-efficient plan.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Your current plan to redirect new contributions into low-cost index funds like FSKAX and FTIHX is excellent and avoids high AUM fees.
Areas to Focus
- • Hire a fee-only fiduciary advisor for a one-time consultation to create a tax-efficient liquidation strategy rather than paying ongoing AUM fees.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Paying a 1.6% annual management fee on your assets will significantly erode your long-term compounding and retirement timeline.
The Original Post
I’m 33 and looking for a gut check on a financial advisor’s recommendation. Current situation: \- Taxable brokerage: $314K, 100% FBGRX (Fidelity Blue Chip Growth) \- Roth IRA: $52K, 100% FXAIX (S&P 500) \- No debt \- $100k in a 3.3% HYSA (thinking of moving 40k to brokerage) \- $220k TC I previously worked for a company with significant investment restrictions, which limited what I could invest in. Now in a new job and have more options. My advisor (through Fidelity) recommends gradually selling FBGRX and moving the taxable account into a diversified managed portfolio for a 1.6% annual fee. The rationale is diversification + managing the sell-down in a tax-efficient way. I agree I’m too concentrated and want to diversify. My hesitation is: \- 1.6% feels steep for something I could potentially accomplish with low-cost index funds. \- I don’t know how to sell off the $314K tax-efficiently (which lots to sell, how much per year, tax-loss harvesting, etc.). This is where professional help seems valuable. \- I haven’t saved as much as I’d like over the past 2 years, so I’d rather avoid realizing gains in 2026 and creating an additional tax bill next spring. \- I may use a meaningful portion of this account for a home purchase in late 2028/2029. My alternative: Stop contributing to FBGRX now, put all new investments into diversified funds (thinking FSKAX + FTIHX), leave FBGRX alone through 2026, then start a tax-conscious sell-down in January 2027. I’d separately de-risk money earmarked for the house as I get closer. Would you pay 1.6% AUM for professional management in this situation? Or would I be better off paying a CPA/fee-only fiduciary to develop a tax-efficient sell-down/allocation plan and managing the portfolio myself? Also curious whether waiting until January to start selling FBGRX is reasonable or if I’m letting taxes drive the investment decision too much.