FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

33-Year-Old with $824k Realizes the 401(k) Tax Advantage They've Been Missing

r/coastFIRE
11/2/2025
Age
33
Net Worth
$824,000
Expenses
$60,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

33-year-old with $824k net worth realizes they may have missed optimal tax strategy by only contributing 5% to 401(k) while building substantial taxable accounts for early retirement.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Building a diverse portfolio across taxable ($488k), 401(k) ($225k), Roth IRA ($72k), and HSA ($39k). Planning for modest $60k annual withdrawals to stay in 0% LTCG bracket.

Areas to Focus

  • • Maximize 401(k) contributions going forward to take advantage of current 24% tax bracket versus expected 12% withdrawal bracket in retirement, even with early withdrawal considerations.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Having too much money in taxable accounts could lead to missed tax optimization opportunities. Without information on current income and savings rate, it's unclear if the FI by 40 goal is realistic.

The Original Post

I'm 33. These are my numbers: $488k in taxable accounts. $225k in 401k. $72k in Roth IRA. $39k in HSA. From the beginning of my career I've only contributed enough for company match (5%) in my 401k. I've been planning to FI by 40, so I emphasized investing money in "more accessible" taxable accounts, even if I knew the 401k may *eventually* be better for taxes. I'm now realizing that the 401k might actually *always* be better for taxes and I needed to check with you guys instead of google or an llm at this point. My situation isn't what you might think. I'm not worried about the capital gains tax. My spend/withdrawal in RE would be $60k, keeping me in the 0% LTCG bracket (counting standard deduction). However, I got thinking - I was paying 24% tax at the top of my bracket. The day I do hypothetically pull money out of my 401k, I'd be in the 12% bracket. Even in a *worst case scenario* where I'm under 55 and decide to pay the 10% penalty, that'd still only be 22% total. And of course you have Roth conversions and SEPPs as options to not pay the penalty. So it seems, if you plan for modest withdrawals during retirement, even if it's really early, it's always the right choice to max your 401k (along with building a sufficient bridge account). I can't think of any downsides.