Rental vs. Capital Gains: Should This 33-Year-Old Hold a 3% Rate Property?
- Age
- 33
- Net Worth
- $864,000
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 33-year-old couple holds $700k in savings and a rental property, aiming for retirement at 55 while weighing the tax implications of selling their former home.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a solid base of $700k at 33 and a rental that cash flows $750/month, which is an excellent start for your FIRE journey.
Areas to Focus
- • Consult a tax professional regarding the 'Section 121' home sale exclusion rule to see if you can maximize tax-free gains before the May 2028 deadline.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ The primary risk is the opportunity cost of tying up your equity in a single property versus potentially higher-growth investment vehicles for your HCOL relocation.
The Original Post
I bought my house in 2021 for $295k, and is now worth $375k (currently owe $206k at 3%). I moved out of state in May of 2025 and starting renting it out in September 2025. I am renting it out for $2,475/month (10% property management fee, so cash flowing about $750 a month after all expenses). I hope to retire early at 55. Wife and I currently have $700k in retirement savings and are 33 now. Should I keep it long term so it will help supplement my retirement income after 55? Or should I sell it before May of 2028 so I don't have to pay capital gains taxes on the increase in value? My wife and I are also planning to move to a HCOL area in summer of 2028 after she finishes residency, so we'd like to use this equity on a down payment for our new house in that location, but losing that 3% rate is going to sting.