Is a DB Pension the Missing Key to My CoastFIRE Dream at 34?
- Age
- 34
- Net Worth
- $109,000
- Expenses
- $102,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 34 with $509k in investments and strong DB pensions, this married parent of two is navigating how to factor guaranteed income into their CoastFIRE strategy.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Your current combined investments of $509,000 are a solid foundation for retirement, and including the pension in your projection is standard practice for long-term planning.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a retirement projection that explicitly values your pension at a conservative withdrawal rate to see how much of your $9k monthly expenses it truly covers.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-reliance on a single employer for your retirement security, which creates 'Golden Handcuffs' and limits your career flexibility.
The Original Post
I've been wrestling with whether I truly qualify as Coast FIRE. From what I understand, Coast FIRE means you've already accumulated enough invested assets Here's my situation: * Mid-career. 34 y/o, married, two kids under 3. * Household Investments of: * TFSA: 249K * RRSP: 232K * RESP: 28K * Wife and I both have a defined benefit (DB) pension through work. These pensions typically provide about 1.4% to 2.0% of pensionable earnings per year of service, meaning someone with a full career could receive roughly 50% to 70% of their pre-retirement salary as a lifetime pension. * Mortgage just shy of 400K on 750K home. * Current monthly spend of 8-9K If I exclude the pension, my invested assets probably aren't enough to reach my retirement target on their own. If I include the future pension payments as part of my retirement income, then I'm comfortably on track and arguably already Coast FIRE. The question is, does a DB pension "count" for Coast FIRE purposes? On one hand, it feels reasonable because it's a guaranteed retirement asset that I'm earning through my employment. On the other hand, I still need to keep working for a number of years to earn the full pension benefit, which seems different from having a portfolio that can compound independently. For those of you with government, military, teacher, utility, or other DB pensions: * Do you include the present value of your pension when calculating Coast FIRE? * Would you consider someone Coast FIRE if their investment portfolio alone isn't sufficient, but their portfolio + future DB pension is? * Is there a distinction between being Coast FIRE based on assets already earned in the pension versus future years of pension accrual that haven't happened yet? * Should I still save into investment accounts?- TSFA, RRSP- (I will max kids RESPs) Curious how others think about this. Sometimes I feel like I'm Coast FIRE, and other times I wonder if I'm just "Coast FIRE contingent on not leaving my employer." What do you think?