FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Should This 34-Year-Old Engineer Making $220k Switch His 401(k) to Roth?

r/ChubbyFIRE
9/22/2025
Age
34
Net Worth
$1,015,000
Income
$220,000/yr
Profession
Engineer
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This 34-year-old engineer has an impressive net worth of $1.015 million, with $400k in his 401(k) and $200k in his spouse's 401(k). He's considering switching his 401(k) to a Roth 401(k) to take advantage of tax-free growth and withdrawals in retirement. With a high income and generous employer match, he has the means to max out both traditional and Roth accounts.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • This individual is maxing out retirement accounts, has a high net worth, and is on track to accumulate over $10 million in retirement savings by age 60 based on their 7-10% growth projections.

Areas to Focus

  • • Consider the state tax implications of switching to a Roth 401(k) versus keeping the traditional 401(k), as this could impact the overall tax efficiency of their retirement plan.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ If their spouse does not return to the workforce as planned, their household income and savings rate could be impacted, which may require adjustments to their FIRE timeline or spending in retirement.

The Original Post

My company is starting to offer a Roth 401k next year. I’m thinking it’s good time to switch and I want to see if anyone has holes in my logic. Income: I just increased to $175k + $45k bonus. Company matches 401k at 12% (amazing) so about $23k/year +growth. All in pretax. I have to put 6% to get match but it can be in Roth. Spouse makes $75k part time but will quit job in March after RSU vest and bonus. Shortly before kid #2. She will be a SAHM. The recently increased salary should allow me to continue maxing out my 401k even when my spouse isn’t working. Investment: mostly VOO/VTI My 401k: $400k Spouse 401k: $200k Roth IRA: $155k Taxable: $200k Cash and HYSA: $50k 529: $10k Mortgage: $440k soon to be refinanced at 5.5% over 20 years. Forever home. I’m 34 and realistically plan to work until at least 50. I can’t say I’ll be with this company forever, but right now I definitely can’t do better and I don’t hate my job. Spouse plans to return to work at some point, but likely in a lower paying field. We won’t need it, but we will likely inherit 7 figures in a mix of accounts. We also typically are gifted $18k. We plan to support our kids through annual gifting, college undergrad, weddings, etc and generally want to set up generational wealth. Rough 401k math if I work until 50 and let it grow until 60 while maxing every year at 23k. Account balances at 60: Trad 401k: $4.4M (7%) to $9.6M (10%) Roth 401k: $1.4M (7%) to $2.4M (10%) Or Trad 401k: $6M (7%) to $12.5M (10%) Logic: It seems that even switching to Roth I will still have enough in my traditional 401k to fill up all of the lower brackets in retirement because of the generous company match. Current marginal bracket is 24% now or 22% when my wife stops working. We’d likely be pushing into much higher brackets in retirement if we were sitting on $12M pretax at 60. Those Roth dollars may never be needed other than for tax efficient spending, so they will continue to grow and become a better inheritance for our kids. Who knows what future tax brackets will look like. My only reservation is that my state taxes are 4.8% and retirement funds are not taxed on withdrawals but Roth 401k would be subject to state tax at time of investment. Anything else I’m not thinking about? Should I make the switch?