Seeking a Household CFO: Optimizing Financial Planning for a $475k Income Couple
- Age
- 35
- Net Worth
- $1,095,000
- Income
- $475,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This couple is balancing a $475k income and $1M net worth while seeking the best advisory model to transition from investment management to comprehensive financial planning.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a strong foundation with $1M in equity and high earnings. Transitioning to a flat-fee or fee-only CFP could save you significant long-term costs compared to AUM fees.
Areas to Focus
- • Evaluate and document your exact annual expenses to determine your FIRE number and required withdrawal strategies.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Concentration risk in employer stock and tax inefficiency from high variable comp and real estate management.
The Original Post
My wife (43) and I (35) are trying to decide what type of financial-advisory relationship makes the most sense as our finances get more complicated. We’re both W-2 earners with household compensation generally around **$450k–$500k+**, depending on variable comp. I’m comfortable with investing and personal finance, and I like understanding why something is being recommended. I’m also willing to implement recommendations myself if that ends up being the best model. Very roughly, our financial picture looks like this: * **Cash:** \~$250k–$300k in the accounts we've consolidated so far; waiting to invest with the right plan * **Traditional/Roth IRAs:** about $100k * **Taxable professionally managed account:** about $135k * **Other taxable brokerage:** "play money" investing \~$10k * **Employer stock:** roughly $65k–$70k vested and roughly $35k–$40k unvested RSUs * **Employer retirement accounts:** additional retirement assets outside the figures above * **Crypto:** separate holdings, but not the main driver of the decision * **Real estate:** primary residence ($1m) plus one rental property, with roughly $500k+ of combined home equity based on current estimates * Rental is approximately breakeven before maintenance/capex/vacancy, so it creates planning and tax complexity rather than a large current cash-flow stream I’m currently with a traditional Baird private-wealth team. About $230k is in advisory accounts, and I’m paying 1.15% AUM. The team is experienced, but my relationship has historically felt more **investment-management-focused than comprehensive-planning-focused**. What I increasingly want is more of a **household CFO** relationship: someone who can look across everything rather than primarily manage a securities portfolio. The areas where I think professional advice could be most valuable are: * tax planning around high W-2 income, variable comp and RSUs * retirement contribution/withdrawal strategy and asset location * employer-stock concentration * taxable investing * rental-property and real-estate decisions * insurance * estate planning * cash management * coordinating all of the above into one long-term plan I’m mainly considering two approaches, but realize there are others that may better suit our situation: **1. Advice-only / flat-fee CFP** **2. Full-service discretionary RIA** I’m not opposed to paying several thousand dollars a year for good financial advice. What I’m questioning is whether **AUM is the right way to pay for it**, especially since our assets should grow substantially over the next couple of decades while the complexity of our financial plan may not increase proportionally. And if so, is a RIA better than a Baird/JPM/UBS/etc. For people who have dealt with a similar decision: * Would you lean toward an advice-only/flat-fee CFP in this situation? * If you’re financially comfortable and willing to implement recommendations, what do you actually gain from paying someone to manage the investments too? * Has anyone used a core-and-satellite arrangement successfully? * For those using a full-service RIA, what services beyond portfolio management make the ongoing fee worthwhile? * At what asset level did AUM pricing start feeling difficult to justify? * Are there important drawbacks to the flat-fee/advice-only model that I’m overlooking? I’m less interested in finding someone who can just “beat the market” and more interested in finding the right structure for **comprehensive financial decision-making without paying unnecessarily for portfolio management I may not need** (and also outperform the market)**.**