FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Selling the Business at 35: Navigating a $1.7M Portfolio Shift to Passive Investing

r/coastFIRE
5/25/2026
Age
35
Net Worth
$1,724,000
Expenses
$66,000/yr
Profession
Sales Rep
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

After selling a business and accumulating $1.7M, this 35-year-old sales rep is evaluating a shift toward a more efficient, self-managed portfolio strategy.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have built an incredible foundation. Transitioning to low-cost index funds like VTI/VXUS is a mathematically sound strategy that likely outperforms high-fee active management.

Areas to Focus

  • • Evaluate the tax impact of firing Mike versus the long-term drag of a 1.25% management fee, then execute a phased transition to your chosen index funds.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-reliance on active management and high expense ratios could silently erode your long-term compounding growth.

The Original Post

Making a big financial decision and looking for advice from internet strangers 😄 35M. No kids, not married, not buying house. Total invested net worth: about $1.724M. I’ve had two financial advisors/managers: * Dan for 6 years. He currently manages mostly income-producing investments because I sold my business 1.5 years ago and wasn’t sure whether the new owner would keep me on. Fortunately he did, and I now make enough as a 1099 sales rep to fully cover my monthly expenses (\~$5,500/mo), so I no longer currently need portfolio income, but that could change - the new owner is weirdly wishy washy. * Mike buys individual stocks. Charges 1.25%. Dan charges 0.83%, but with underlying fund expense ratios it’s probably closer to 1.3-1.5% all-in. I’m considering: * firing Mike completely (investing in VTI is doing better than his 70 stocks) * keeping Dan, but only having him manage 40% of my portfolio (\~$690k) * self-managing the other 60% (\~$1.03M) Reasoning: * avoids triggering massive capital gains taxes all at once * still keeps an advisor/safety net * Dan could shift toward growth now, but “turn on” income (\~$35k/year) later if I lose my job or want optionality. There is something special about dividends covering your monthly expenses and having work be optional. My self-managed allocation would probably be: * 80% VTI * 10% VXUS * 10% SCHD Retirement accounts: * likely all VTI Taxable brokerage: * VTI / VXUS / SCHD Emergency fund: * increasing from $30k to $60k (roughly 1 year expenses) Any excess monthly income I earn going forward would likely continue going mostly into VTI, with some SCHD so I can gradually learn how dividend investing works myself and maybe eventually not need Dan. Am I overcomplicating this? Is it insane to put roughly: * $827k in VTI * $103k in VXUS * $103k in SCHD at 35 years old? Or does this hybrid approach actually make sense given the job uncertainty / tax considerations?