Selling the Business at 35: Navigating a $1.7M Portfolio Shift to Passive Investing
- Age
- 35
- Net Worth
- $1,724,000
- Expenses
- $66,000/yr
- Profession
- Sales Rep
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
After selling a business and accumulating $1.7M, this 35-year-old sales rep is evaluating a shift toward a more efficient, self-managed portfolio strategy.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have built an incredible foundation. Transitioning to low-cost index funds like VTI/VXUS is a mathematically sound strategy that likely outperforms high-fee active management.
Areas to Focus
- • Evaluate the tax impact of firing Mike versus the long-term drag of a 1.25% management fee, then execute a phased transition to your chosen index funds.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-reliance on active management and high expense ratios could silently erode your long-term compounding growth.
The Original Post
Making a big financial decision and looking for advice from internet strangers 😄 35M. No kids, not married, not buying house. Total invested net worth: about $1.724M. I’ve had two financial advisors/managers: * Dan for 6 years. He currently manages mostly income-producing investments because I sold my business 1.5 years ago and wasn’t sure whether the new owner would keep me on. Fortunately he did, and I now make enough as a 1099 sales rep to fully cover my monthly expenses (\~$5,500/mo), so I no longer currently need portfolio income, but that could change - the new owner is weirdly wishy washy. * Mike buys individual stocks. Charges 1.25%. Dan charges 0.83%, but with underlying fund expense ratios it’s probably closer to 1.3-1.5% all-in. I’m considering: * firing Mike completely (investing in VTI is doing better than his 70 stocks) * keeping Dan, but only having him manage 40% of my portfolio (\~$690k) * self-managing the other 60% (\~$1.03M) Reasoning: * avoids triggering massive capital gains taxes all at once * still keeps an advisor/safety net * Dan could shift toward growth now, but “turn on” income (\~$35k/year) later if I lose my job or want optionality. There is something special about dividends covering your monthly expenses and having work be optional. My self-managed allocation would probably be: * 80% VTI * 10% VXUS * 10% SCHD Retirement accounts: * likely all VTI Taxable brokerage: * VTI / VXUS / SCHD Emergency fund: * increasing from $30k to $60k (roughly 1 year expenses) Any excess monthly income I earn going forward would likely continue going mostly into VTI, with some SCHD so I can gradually learn how dividend investing works myself and maybe eventually not need Dan. Am I overcomplicating this? Is it insane to put roughly: * $827k in VTI * $103k in VXUS * $103k in SCHD at 35 years old? Or does this hybrid approach actually make sense given the job uncertainty / tax considerations?