Building Dreams or Debt? Navigating a $700k Mortgage Decision in Our Mid-30s
- Age
- 35
- Net Worth
- $130,000
- Income
- $180,000/yr
- Expenses
- $60,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This mid-30s couple is weighing a $420k home build against repairing their aging modular home, aiming to balance long-term value with monthly cash flow.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a solid income of $180k+ and effectively no debt outside of the mortgage, which provides a great foundation for wealth building.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a detailed cost-benefit analysis on the energy savings of a new build versus the $30k repair cost to see if the ROI justifies the added $4100 annual mortgage interest increase.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Overextending on a $700k total mortgage could significantly strain your cash flow and slow your ability to reach FIRE, especially if overtime income fluctuates.
The Original Post
My wife and I, in our mid-30s, bought acreage with a modular home for a 260k loan. It is our only note, and we are valued at around 420k at this moment. Our home is approximately 20-25 years old and has issues that need addressing, and it would probably cost us around 30k to fix the home incrementally, but this would not fix everything because our electrical bills are substantial due to poor building quality, etc. These Modular homes just aren't built the best. We have recently begun discussions to build a home or purchase a new manufactured home (priced around 220k). Our bills are zero; everything is paid off, minus the home, which is currently about 2900 a month (thanks to high interest rates). But combined, we spend approximately 4-5k a month with living expenses etc. Income is approximately 160-200k depending on my overtime annually, between us both. I am tax-exempt as well from the VA. New home is gonna be 420k, leaving our total loan at almost 700k. A mortgage calculator is putting us around 3600 a month in payments for that amount. Is it a smart investment to build long-term? I am nervous to place another modular home and 20 years later experience the same issues. That being said at almost double the cost, a real home is financially more stressful. Any advice is appreciated.