35-Year-Old Finance Professional Ready to Ditch Morgan Stanley's 1% Fees
- Age
- 35
- Net Worth
- $130,000
- Profession
- Finance
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
A 35-year-old finance professional with $130k in an advisory account is questioning high fees and active management, considering a switch to self-managed index funds.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • With a strong foundation of $130k saved at age 35 and professional background in finance, you have the skills to successfully transition to low-cost index funds.
Areas to Focus
- • Consolidate your 54 overlapping positions into a simple, low-cost three-fund index portfolio at Schwab.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Continuing to pay over 1% in unnecessary management and fund fees will steadily erode your long-term compounding returns.
The Original Post
So I've got about $130K with Morgan Stanley, mostly in an advisory IRA (around $107K). The fee is about 0.9%, and with the fund expenses on top I'm probably paying 1.1 to 1.4% a year total. I pulled my holdings and activity a while back and went through everything. The returns are fine. After fees I'm up about 8% this year and around 9 to 10% a year since I opened it. But some stuff really bugged me. Last year they bought six stocks on the same day and sold them all a few months later at a loss. It's an IRA, so those losses don't even help me on taxes. They also swapped some funds for other funds that do pretty much the same thing. And there were stretches where a good chunk just sat in cash doing nothing while I kept paying the fee on it. There are also 54 positions in there, including 36 individual stocks and 16 bond funds. That seems like a lot for an account this size. I'm 35 and I work in finance, so I'm comfortable managing this myself. I already have a couple of robo IRAs at Schwab and I've been putting new money there. I just don't want to make a move I regret because I'm annoyed. What I'm wondering: At this size, is an advisor worth what I'm paying, or should I just go index funds or a robo? If you've left a big firm, did you move everything over as is or sell first? Anything that tripped you up? Is it worth asking them to lower the fee, or do they not really budge? I'm planning to decide in January. Would love to hear what you guys would do. I am part of a large family estate I cannot reach, so my link depends on being a beneficiary in the family structure. Because I am between jobs, I moved my coverage from my employer’s plan to theirs.