FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

35-Year-Old NYC Millionaire Weighs Renting vs Selling $900k Home - Can He Retire Early?

r/coastFIRE
9/15/2025
Age
35
Net Worth
$2,100,000
Expenses
$80,000/yr
Location
New York City, NY
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 35 years old with a $2.1M net worth, this NYC-based professional is ready to transition into early retirement. With a mortgage-free $900k home, $1.6M in liquid investments, and a projected $80k annual budget, he's on the cusp of financial independence. The key decisions he faces are whether to keep renting out his NYC property or sell it, and whether to buy or rent a new home outside the city to reduce his cost of living.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • With $2.1M in net worth, a mortgage-free home, and $1.6M in liquid investments, this individual is extremely well-positioned for early retirement. Their projected $80k annual expenses can likely be covered by a 4% withdrawal rate from their investment portfolio.

Areas to Focus

  • • The primary action to take is deciding whether to keep the NYC property as a rental or sell it. Renting it out could provide additional income, but also comes with management headaches. Selling may simplify his finances and allow him to purchase a lower-cost home outside the city.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The biggest risk factor is the uncertainty around his actual annual expenses, especially healthcare costs. It will be important to closely track and refine his budget before fully committing to retirement.

The Original Post

Hey folks! Long time lurker, first-time poster here. I'm fully burnt out of my profession and ready (emotionally) to call it quits. I've already gotten a wealth of insight from this sub (thank you!), but I'd love some feedback on my overall readiness. First off, I'm 35M and single, and my current NW is \~$2.1M: * 401k: $740k * Brokerage: $840k * Home equity: \~$900k (-$510k mortgage) * Savings: $120k My mortgage is in a VHCOL area (NYC) and a relatively good rate (3.375%). If I stay in the city, I'm \*not quite\* at the 4% rule for full FIRE (I'm projecting \~$80k annual budget but I'm not confident, with things like health insurance to factor), but I'm working on exploring potential Coast income. However, I'm also considering moving outside the city to lower my COL. First off: any advice on how long I should try to make Coast FIRE work in my NYC apartment before deciding I should try to move? I'd rather stay if I can but I'm primarily in the city for my current job, so it naturally feels untenable to stay put without the income (even if that's not true). Secondly: If I do leave NYC, should I hold onto the NYC property to rent it out (my condo allows for monthly leases, which I like the flexibility of) or am I better off selling? I was strongly considering the former, but I've recently seen a few threads on the sub that seem to strongly favor \*not\* renting out, so I'd appreciate more perspectives. And finally: Given my financial goals and situation, if I move out of the city, am I in a better position looking to buy or rent a new home (taking into account the current mortgage rates)? Thanks in advance for your expertise!