Navigating the 457b Maze: A 35-Year-Old Couple's Strategy for Early Retirement
- Age
- 35
- Net Worth
- $350,000
- Income
- $210,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 35-year-old couple is strategically managing a $350k portfolio while navigating the complexities of 457b plans as they aim for retirement between ages 50 and 55.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Continue prioritizing matching contributions and tax-advantaged accounts like the Mega-Backdoor Roth while paying down high-interest debt.
Areas to Focus
- • Thoroughly review the specific summary plan description of the non-governmental 457b to understand the employer's specific payout options upon separation.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ The potential loss of 457b assets to general creditors if the employer faces bankruptcy is a significant non-market risk that should be weighed against the tax benefits.
The Original Post
I'm currently in the search for a new job. I have experience with, and understand 401k, 403b, and IRAs; roth vs pre-tax vs after-tax... I'm good with all of it. What I'm having an issue with is that I got an offer from a new employer that utilizes a non-governmental 457b plan. I understand the pro of being able to access the money before age 59.5 penalty free. But I do have concerns. The facts as I understand them state that when you are separated from a 457b company, they can force a lump sum distribution, or allow for 5, 10 or 15 year dispersals. You cannot roll over into an IRA or other retirement vehicle. This seems to be a massive drawback. From what I understand, that means the day you retire, you could be forced to withdraw YOUR ENTIRE RETIREMENT BALANCE in the 457b. That seems insane in terms of financial planning. Why do I see so many things online about a 457b being a great thing when it seems like it has such a big downside. My husband and I (both 35) have approximately $350k in other retirement accounts (IRAs, 403b's, 401k's, and a mix of roth/traditional). My husband has access to a 403b and I am overemployed with additional access to a 401k that allows after-tax contributions for the mega-backdoor roth conversions. We'll likely be able to put away about 40k a year on 210k salary into our retirement accounts (mix of pre and post tax). We're looking for any insight or opinions on why you like a 457b and if it would have any value in our scenario. Currently, we're looking at doing the following until we understand more about the 457b: * $6.5k pre-tax into the 457b to get the company match from my main job * $3k pre-tax into the 403b to get the company match from my husbands job * $1k pre-tax into the 401k to get the company match from my second job * $7500 into our roth IRAs * $15k into his roth 403b We'd like to retire around 50-55 so roth plans are important to us. Currently a lot of our money goes into aggressive pay down of our home and student loans which will both be gone in <10 years. If we're missing something about our 457b plans that would make more sense in our situation, please let us know. But as it stands right now, the 457b seems more of a headache (not even counting the whole "if the hospital goes bankrupt, it can take your 457b" )