The $3M Paradox: Why This NYC Dad Chose Private School Over Early Retirement
- Age
- 35
- Net Worth
- $3,000,000
- Profession
- High earning professional
- Location
- NYC
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
35-year-old with $3M net worth discovers fatherhood and flexible work-life balance make early retirement less urgent than enriching kids' present.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You've built $3M net worth by 35 with $2M liquid, putting you ahead of 99% of people your age. Your work-life balance is already optimized with flexible 40-hour weeks and short commute. You're thinking holistically about ROI on family experiences vs pure FIRE timeline.
Areas to Focus
- • Define your actual annual spending with kids and private school costs to calculate your true FIRE number - you may be closer than you think if $5M target doesn't account for reduced expenses post-retirement.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Lifestyle creep in high-cost NYC with private school tuition could push your FIRE target from $5M to $8M+ if expenses aren't capped - one elite private school can cost $60k/year per child, requiring $1.5M additional nest egg per kid.
The Original Post
35m, $3m NW, $2m liquid, $5m target I fully expected that I would be even more resolved to retire even earlier now that I have kids. I thought I would be motivated to stack more because of how expensive they are. I thought I would want to be FIREd to spend more time with them while they’re young. All those things aren’t untrue, but I think I underestimated several things: - My job is already flexible and my commute is short. I’m not missing activities because I can’t leave work. - I work 40 hours a week, maybe 50 during a serious crunch. - Once I’m realistically able to retire (late 40s, early 50s), the kids will be busy anyway. - NYC kid stuff is built for working parents, especially those with $$ I think if someone could give me another $3m today, I would retire right now, but now retiring at 45 vs 55 seems more about my preferences than the family. Right now if I had to choose between saving $100k a year and retiring 10 years earlier vs sending them to the posh, progressive private school of my dreams and retiring only a little earlier, I’m surprised that I think I’d spend it on them now. I really didn’t expect to reach this conclusion! Note: I’m posting this here vs main fire because I think this choice has so much inherent privilege.