FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

The $3M Paradox: Why This NYC Dad Chose Private School Over Early Retirement

r/ChubbyFIRE
12/9/2025
Age
35
Net Worth
$3,000,000
Profession
High earning professional
Location
NYC
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

35-year-old with $3M net worth discovers fatherhood and flexible work-life balance make early retirement less urgent than enriching kids' present.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You've built $3M net worth by 35 with $2M liquid, putting you ahead of 99% of people your age. Your work-life balance is already optimized with flexible 40-hour weeks and short commute. You're thinking holistically about ROI on family experiences vs pure FIRE timeline.

Areas to Focus

  • • Define your actual annual spending with kids and private school costs to calculate your true FIRE number - you may be closer than you think if $5M target doesn't account for reduced expenses post-retirement.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Lifestyle creep in high-cost NYC with private school tuition could push your FIRE target from $5M to $8M+ if expenses aren't capped - one elite private school can cost $60k/year per child, requiring $1.5M additional nest egg per kid.

The Original Post

35m, $3m NW, $2m liquid, $5m target I fully expected that I would be even more resolved to retire even earlier now that I have kids. I thought I would be motivated to stack more because of how expensive they are. I thought I would want to be FIREd to spend more time with them while they’re young. All those things aren’t untrue, but I think I underestimated several things: - My job is already flexible and my commute is short. I’m not missing activities because I can’t leave work. - I work 40 hours a week, maybe 50 during a serious crunch. - Once I’m realistically able to retire (late 40s, early 50s), the kids will be busy anyway. - NYC kid stuff is built for working parents, especially those with $$ I think if someone could give me another $3m today, I would retire right now, but now retiring at 45 vs 55 seems more about my preferences than the family. Right now if I had to choose between saving $100k a year and retiring 10 years earlier vs sending them to the posh, progressive private school of my dreams and retiring only a little earlier, I’m surprised that I think I’d spend it on them now. I really didn’t expect to reach this conclusion! Note: I’m posting this here vs main fire because I think this choice has so much inherent privilege.