FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

35-Year-Old Vet with $490k Plans 52 Retirement - But Should He Switch to Traditional Now?

r/financialindependence
11/19/2025
Age
35
Net Worth
$490,000
Income
$130,000/yr
Expenses
$24,000/yr
Profession
Veteran
Location
No state income tax state
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Disciplined 35-year-old veteran with $490k net worth plans retirement at 52 with pension at 57. Strong savings rate and tax strategy in place.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Exceptional savings rate of 81% ($106k saved annually) puts you years ahead of most. Your 10-year Roth foundation ($276k) creates a tax-free withdrawal base that perfectly complements your pension strategy. Smart tax optimization living in a no-income-tax state with tax-exempt compensation maximizes every dollar.

Areas to Focus

  • • Don't wait 2 years to switch to traditional contributions - start NOW while your tax-exempt income gives you the rare advantage of building pre-tax wealth at minimal cost, then convert strategically in lower-income years before pension kicks in at 57.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Your 2-5 year home purchase timeline conflicts with aggressive stock allocation - with $214k HYSA you're likely holding too much cash earning 4-5% while missing 20-35% market returns. Move excess cash (beyond $50k emergency fund plus down payment) into investments immediately, or commit to buying within 12 months to stop the opportunity cost bleed of $10k+ annually.

The Original Post

Hello, I'm 35m vet. Just looking for any advice/recommendations. Here's a link to my current financial situation https://imgur.com/a/cM9ROvs All of my compensation and some of my paycheck is tax exempt and I live in a state with no tax on income. I've been investing with roth 401k/ira for 10+ years (please ignore the slight overage on the chart). I think i will switch my contributions to traditional 401k/ira in 2 years, leaving my existing roth contributions sit and grow. Since when during retirement my roth investments wont be considered for MAGI/AGI taxes I can benefit for the lowest tax bracket when receiving traditional 401k/ira distributions. My stock portfolio consists of high risk etf/mutual funds and have made 20-35% on average. I will continue to max my 401k/ira as the limit increases. As I get closer to retirement I will switch to low risk options about 2 years out depending on the market. I have a comfortable amount in my hysa which would protect me for 2+ years if I were to loose my job. I plan to use a portion of the hysa money for a down payment on a home in the next 2-5 years. I don't have a lot of expenses. I'm a frugal guy, cook all of my meals, live close to work, have an electric vehicle that I usually drive and charge at work. I didn't include additional expense categories because after calculatingthe past 3 years they're below $1000 annually. All my purchases are made using 3 reward credit cards (2% on all purchases and 3-5% on rotating categories) and payoff monthly. I didn't include the APY from those or the HYSA but it's around 6k annually (1099-INT). I have no cc/car/student debts. As far as retirement, I would like to retire at 52, and live off compensation, standard investments and savings until I can receive my pension at 57 (35-40k a year) and withdraw my roth investments at 59.5. I'll try to respond to any follow-up questions quickly. Thanks everyone in advance!