Coast FIRE at 35: Can This Couple Stop Saving for Their Dream House and Still Hit $3M by 65?
- Age
- 35
- Net Worth
- $550,000
- Expenses
- $130,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 35 with $550k invested, this couple is exploring whether they can "coast" to their $3M retirement target while reducing savings for a house. Conservative scenarios show they'd reach their goal right around 65, but optimistic returns could get them there in their mid-50s.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Strong financial foundation with $550k at age 35 and stable dual income. Employer-matching contributions (7% match) will continue building wealth even if they coast, providing meaningful automatic growth of $2k/month minimum.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a detailed stress test using conservative 4-5% real returns (not just 7% nominal) across multiple market scenarios to quantify the true buffer zone. The gap between cutting 'just enough' in conservative scenarios vs being comfortably ahead is where the real decision lives.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Over-reliance on optimistic return assumptions to justify scaling back contributions. If market returns revert to 4% real vs hoped-for 7%, the $1,200/month Roth reduction eliminates crucial flexibility and could push retirement to age 65+ with no margin for error (market downturns, job loss, inflation surprises).
The Original Post
I’m trying to figure out whether my wife and I are realistically at (or near) Coast FIRE, but I’m getting very different answers depending on return assumptions and would really appreciate some perspective. **Context:** We both have stable jobs we enjoy, so we’re not trying to retire early (at least right now). The decision we’re weighing is whether to reduce voluntary retirement contributions so we can afford a slightly nicer house in a HCOL area. Our employers require a 7% contribution with a 7% match (14% total), so even if we “coast,” we’re still contributing a meaningful amount automatically. Right now, we’re contributing \~$3,200/month total, including $1,200/month to Roth IRAs. We’re considering stopping the Roth contributions, which would reduce our total monthly investing to \~$2,000 (just the employer-linked contributions). **Stats:** * Age: 35 * Investments: \~$550k (mostly S&P 500 index funds, \~200k in Roth, and 350k in IRA/401k) * Contributions going forward: $2k/month (or $3.2k/month if we continue Roth IRA contributions) * Current expenses: \~$130k/year (includes $24k we’re saving annually towards our down payment and 12k towards our Roth) * Target retirement spend: \~$120k/year ($3m total target with 4% withdrawal) * Target retirement age: 65 **What I’m seeing:** If we drop to \~$2k/month: * At \~7% nominal (\~4% real), we reach \~$3.1M around age 64 (basically just enough) * At \~10% nominal (\~7% real), we’d hit our number much earlier (\~mid-50s) or end up with \~$6M+ by 65 If we continue \~$3.2k/month: * At \~7% nominal, we reach our target closer to age 60 * At \~10% nominal, we hit it around \~52 So the extra $1,200/month mostly shifts timing by a few years in conservative scenarios, but doesn’t dramatically change the end result in more optimistic ones. **Where I’m struggling:** In a conservative scenario, we’re cutting it pretty close to our target retirement age if we scale back contributions. I’d prefer some buffer, but I’m not sure how much is “enough” vs. over-saving at the expense of current quality of life (housing in this case). **Questions:** * What return assumptions (real vs. nominal) do you personally use when evaluating Coast FIRE, and how conservative should we be here? * How much buffer do you aim for beyond your “number” before feeling comfortable coasting (e.g., % over target, years early, etc.)? * Is being \~on track under conservative assumptions (but not comfortably ahead) enough to justify scaling back, or would you personally want a larger margin before doing so? Happy to provide more detail if helpful—appreciate any thoughts.