FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Is Retiring at 50 Realistic? A 35-Year-Old Weighs a $466k Portfolio Against a Long-Term Pension

r/Fire
7/29/2026
Age
35
Net Worth
$766,449
Income
$145,000/yr
Expenses
$40,000/yr
Location
Oregon
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

With $466k invested and a robust corporate pension, this 35-year-old is debating between a 50 or 55-year-old retirement exit, balancing potential market growth against guaranteed healthcare.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You are doing an excellent job with your savings rate and asset allocation; maintaining your disciplined contribution strategy while deploying excess cash is key.

Areas to Focus

  • • Develop a concrete tax-efficient bridge plan to access your retirement funds between age 50 and 59.5, such as a Roth conversion ladder or Rule 72(t) distributions.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The high dependence on future healthcare policy and the psychological challenge of working an extra five years for insurance benefits and a significantly higher pension payout.

The Original Post

Been lurking here a while. It feels like so many posts are people with $2M at 38 and I usually leave feeling behind, but I've got a pension in the mix that I genuinely can't figure out how to weigh, so here's everything. Me: 35, 36 in October. Single, no kids, Oregon. The numbers: - Income: ~$145k - 401(k): $227,676 - Roth IRA: $51,230 - Taxable brokerage: $187,543 - Cash: $30,500 - **Total invested: $466,449** - House: paid $265k, dumped about $100k into renovating it, probably worth around $475k now. $175,900 left at 3.25%. Call it $300k in equity. - No other debt. It's all VTSAX, VTIAX, and a total market fund in the 401(k). I don't do anything clever. Going in each year: $24,500 to the 401(k), $4,250 employer match (50% up to 6%), $7,500 to the Roth. After all of that, and after paying for my actual life, I still have about $3,200 a month left over. It has been a while since I have funded my brokerage more. I've been in pile-up-the-cash mode since dropping $45K on an exterior renovation, and now have my emergency fund back to where I'd like it to be. But since reaching that number, it's been piling up in my checking because the AI market stuff has me nervous about valuations and I keep telling myself I'll wait for a better entry point. I know. I know exactly what that is. I'm working on it. Spending: $3,000 to $3,500 a month, and $1,300 of that is the mortgage. So roughly $40k a year, or about $24k if the house were paid off. I think like many of you, I'm living lean right now because I'm building toward something. I don't want to grind for twenty years and then keep spending $24k a year on the other side of it. I want to travel. I want to eat out without doing math first. I'd like a nice car at some point. I want freedom! Ideally I'd like to die with a zero balance and nothing left sitting there. So when I model this I use $70k a year, not my current spend. I'd rather overshoot than get to 50 and find I built a retirement I don't actually want to live in. **The pension** I'm 11 years into Cox Enterprises, which still has a real one. What it pays depends on when I leave and when I turn it on: - Leave at 50, start at 55: $32k/yr - Leave at 55, start at 55: $54k/yr - Leave at 50, start at 65: $64k/yr - Leave at 55, start at 65: $90k/yr - Leave at 65, start at 65: $130k/yr Separately, 20 years of service plus staying until 55 gets me the retiree healthcare plan. I pulled the actual language on this today and it's more specific than I'd been assuming: - Before 65: full medical and pharmacy through Aetna/CVS, for me plus a spouse and any kids under 26. - At 65: I enroll in Medicare A and B, get access to a Cox-sponsored Via Benefits exchange, and Cox puts $2,500/yr into an HRA to offset the cost of coverage. So it's real coverage for the decade from 55 to 64, and then a partial credit after that. **Where I'm stuck** At 6% real I land somewhere around $1.85M at 50 if nothing changes, and closer to $2.5M if I actually deploy that $3,200 a month. Both cover $70k at 4% before the pension does anything at all. So on paper, 50 works. But three things keep chewing at me. 1. The bridge. Almost everything I have is tax-advantaged. If I stop at 50 I need to get from 50 to 59.5, and I have not actually built that plan out yet. Big hole here. 2. 50 vs 55. Five more years turns $32k into $90k and covers me through the worst decade of the insurance gap. That's a stupid return on five years of work. But I'm already 11 years in, and when I say "twenty more years" out loud it lands like a prison sentence. Five years at 50 is also not the same five years as at 35, and I'm aware of that. 3. Healthcare from 50 to 65 is the piece I can't model. I have no idea what the individual market (or the world, frankly) looks like in 15 or 20 years. The rules have already moved once recently and they'll move again. That uncertainty is exactly why the Cox coverage is hard to price. It's the only line item in my whole plan that doesn't depend on what Congress does. If I leave at 50 I'm buying my own insurance for fifteen years under rules nobody can predict. If I stay to 55 I've got ten of the worst of those years handled. I don't know how to put a number on that and I'd like to hear how other people have. 4. The pension is annoyingly well suited to what I actually want. If the goal is spending it all and dying at zero, guaranteed income you can't outlive is the one thing that lets you draw down aggressively without white-knuckling it. So the longer I think about the lifestyle I want, the stronger the case for 55 gets, which is not the conclusion I was hoping to reach. **What I'm asking** - Am I in a good spot for my age? - Is 50 realistic here, or am I missing something obvious? Should I strongly consider holding out until 55? - How do you value a pension against a portfolio? Do you treat it as a bond allocation, an income floor, run an NPV on it? It changes my whole allocation question and I don't have a framework for it. - Anyone here walk away from a big deferred benefit like this? Did you regret it? Happy to answer whatever.